Defensively: Matthews > McDavid for sure. Also, in Goals: Matthews is = McDavid;
Points: Mcdavid > Matthews
I'm not saying Matthews is better than McDavid, but, this shows how close they are, [mod] ...
Yeah we get that McDavid gets 100 points in a season, and, Matthews will get ~85 Points a season, but, there is more to hockey than POINTS ...
Matthews should be in competetion for Selke Trophy if he was not injured, he is one of the games best 2 WAY Players. He's as good as Bergeron defensively. AND NOW .. cue oilers fans who will say
" BUT BUT BUT ... MCDAVID IS GOD .... He is better than MATTHEWS DEFENSIVELY!!!!"
No he's not. Matthews is better than McDavid defensively.
There is a reason why Leafs are top 5 in the NHL ... A lot of it has to do with Auston Matthews Selke-Level defensive play along side his goal scoring ability.
Playoffs Matthews: 4 Goals and 1 assist in 6 Games
Playoffs McDavid: 5 Goals and 4 assists in 13 Games
They are very close in terms of overall skill.