Marner VS Fiala

[Holymakinaw]

Pretty good. He's likely to finish top 10 in the whole league in 5v5 assists, which is impressive as hell. Good year for the Leafs I'd say

Yup. Nylander will finish right around where he did last year.....close to 20 goals and 60 points. And that was without Matthews for so long. We're all quite happy with that, I'd say!!

 

[DatSnipeMatthews]

How the sweet heck is this poll only about 2-1 for Marner?? Marner has significantly outscored him in the nhl. Heck, Marner has a higher PPG in the NHL than Fiala does in the AHL.

 

[Holymakinaw]

How the sweet heck is this poll only about 2-1 for Marner?? Marner has significantly outscored him in the nhl. Heck, Marner has a higher PPG in the NHL than Fiala does in the AHL.

Hmm........I wonder.

 

[MattySnipes]

Over 4500 views, but only 253 total votes?

Hmm...talk about a lot of lurkers looking at poll results then leaving - don't be so scared, leave an opinion or a vote.

 

[BruinLVGA]

Pretty good. He's likely to finish top 10 in the whole league in 5v5 assists, which is impressive as hell. Good year for the Leafs I'd say

He has 55 points in 77 games... Hardly the forecasts seen before the season started...

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

He has 55 points in 77 games... Hardly the forecasts seen before the season started...

can't win em all. He had to step in at center for a good stretch of the year, his PP was ice cold, and he missed out on playing with Matthews for 20 games. and he's still roughly on the same pace as last year. I'd hardly call it a regression and it actually looks like he's taken a small step forward as he's shown he can play at center and has improved his defensive game. All in all, it looks like the Leafs have done better this year like we expected

 

[Isaac Nootin]

Man, the doubling down and refusing to admit wrong is simply astounding.

When all else fails...... but, but, but what about Nylander!!!

 

[LeafFever]

How the sweet heck is this poll only about 2-1 for Marner?? Marner has significantly outscored him in the nhl. Heck, Marner has a higher PPG in the NHL than Fiala does in the AHL.

LOL.

 

[BruinLVGA]

It's always hilarious when people talk about a player regressing when the season isn't over yet.. kinda like @BruinLVGA when he was patting his back earlier in the year for apparently "calling" Marner and Nylander regressing in their second year... Woops. Newsflash: Offensive players usually score in spurts and go through hot streaks throughout the year.

Just wondering do you still hold this opinion?

Man, the doubling down and refusing to admit wrong is simply astounding.

When all else fails...... but, but, but what about Nylander!!!

Poster above mentioned me and NYLANDER. I simply replied to that.

See? If you had read the conversation, you would have avoided making a dumb statement.

 

[DatSnipeMatthews]

Poster above mentioned me and NYLANDER. I simply replied to that.

See? If you had read the conversation, you would have avoided making a dumb statement.

You're just a salty Bruins fan because you know the Leafs have a much brighter future. Outside of Pasta, the Bruins have no young forwards to write home about.

 

[BruinLVGA]

You're just a salty Bruins fan because you know the Leafs have a much brighter future. Outside of Pasta, the Bruins have no young forwards to write home about.

Eight rookies scored their first NHL goal for the Bruins this year, but whatever helps you sleep at night.

 

[DatSnipeMatthews]

Eight rookies scored their first NHL goal for the Bruins this year, but whatever helps you sleep at night.

View attachment 108673

Danton Heinen has a piddly 14 goals to lead your rookies.

The Leafs leading 3 point getters are all 21 and under.

 

[BruinLVGA]

Danton Heinen has a piddly 14 goals to lead your rookies.

The Leafs leading 3 point getters are all 21 and under.

Heinen's 14 goals is twice the combined goals amount of all your rookies.

 

[Atomos2]

Do I still think Fiala has the higher ceiling? Yes. He's the better goal scorer and has relied far less on PP scoring. I still expect Marner to be the better player but I think Fiala has the potential to be a top 3 winger, though I'm not sure he'll reach it.

Marner's had a nice second season, but his production levels aren't really all that far off from last year, he's had a bit more puck luck on the PP but his 5v5 production has remained fairly consistent. His confidence seemed to take a step up once Matthews went down. Bodes well for Leaf fans.

Keep falling down those stairs. You'll make it to the top someday.

Fiala never had a higher ceiling than Marner. Not at any stage in their careers.

 

[The List Of Jericho]

Haven't seen much of Marner this year, but I wouldn't trade Fiala for him so I'm going to go a bit homer here and take the guy who is scoring more goals in fewer games.

This is comical lol

 

[The List Of Jericho]

Heinen's 14 goals is twice the combined goals amount of all your rookies.

View attachment 108691

View attachment 108693

Lmao 4 of those guys are defenceman who haven't played more than half the year and the only forward has played a measly 7 games lol

 

[The List Of Jericho]

The poll is asking who has been better this year. Marner has comfortably proven this, based on his play this year compared to Fiala? Seriously. On what basis have you arrived to this conclusion?

The near 70 points that Marner has over Fiala's 46 for one

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Whiskey has a serious bias towards American-born players.

Is that why I voted Marner over Boeser (a minority opinion).

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Fiala has a higher oiSH% on the PP than Marner does this year with the same amount of minutes. You can't credit Marner with puck luck on the PP and not Fiala. Marner's puck-luck at 5v5 has also gone down.

I was talking in comparison to Marner's rookie year, not Fiala.

 

[Atomos2]

Heinen's 14 goals is twice the combined goals amount of all your rookies.

You know 5 of those rookies are D right? And one of those D you referenced has a better GPG than him

Maybe you should have an intervention with the other one of your fellow fans who thinks Heinen=Marner

 

[BruinLVGA]

Lmao 4 of those guys are defenceman who haven't played more than half the year and the only forward has played a measly 7 games lol

Then maybe he shouldn't have mentioned "rookies".

 

[BruinLVGA]

You know 5 of those rookies are D right? And one of those D you referenced has a better GPG than him

Maybe you should have an intervention with the other one of your fellow fans who thinks Heinen=Marner

Speak about "rookies", get an answer about rookies.

 

[Raging Bull]

Who the f*** is Heinen and who cares, this is a Fiala vs Marner poll.

 

[Atomos2]

Speak about "rookies", get an answer about rookies.

Rookie defenceman Holl has a greater GPG than rookie forward Heinen