Proposal: Marner trade ideas

[Ashep]

Tor - Fla
To Toronto:
Huberdeau
Weegar
Tippett

To Florida:
Marner
Dermott

Tor-Min
To Toronto:
Eriksson Ek
Greenway
Dumba

To Minny:
Marner
Dermott

Tor-Cgy
To Toronto:
Tkachuk

To Calgary:
Marner

OR
To Toronto:
Gaudreau
Bennett

To Calgary:
Marner

Click to read more...

 

[DropTheGloves]

A truly exceptional proposal, rare in both the detail provided and the way it balances needs for all teams involved. A+ would read again.

 

[MakeCgyGreatAgain]

Not a chance Florida takes that.

 

[The don godfather]

Debrusk and carlo

 

[Drive425]

Not sure this moves the needle for Florida considering they're eating around 5 million in cap. Huberdeau is pretty much untouchable and on a good contract.

 

[blankall]

Huberdeau is really good. Plus the difference in cap of $5 million is worth a huge amount. Hilarious that Florida is adding to the deal.

 

[Mickey Marner]

I'd do the Tkachuk one.

 

[TheImpatientPanther]

Huberdeau, Weegar and Tippett combined cap hits will likely still be cheaper than Marner's.

FLA says no fairly easily.

Guess you think Dermott = Weegar and Marner = Huberdeau + Tippett?

 

[Volica]

The Minny one would be good for both teams.

Minny gets an offensive catalyst, that they haven’t had... since... Marian Gaborik?

Leafs get a solid Dman, size and a solid middle 6 piece that could elevate playing with Matthews or Tavares.

 

[BigDaddyLurch]

You're only going to get quantity for Marner; that cap hit is a killer...

 

[blankall]

Tor - Fla
To Toronto:
Huberdeau
Weegar
Tippett

To Florida:
Marner
Dermott

This is even worse than the first one. People comment that your proposal is bad, so now Florida is adding one of their top prospects?

Tor-Cgy
To Toronto:
Tkachuk

To Calgary:
Marner

OR
To Toronto:
Gaudreau
Bennett

To Calgary:
Marner

As a Flames fan....these aren't bad. Would do #2 for sure. The issue would be unloading the cap, so it might not work.

 

[AKL]

Wouldn't do that Minnesota one from a Minnesota POV.

 

[YP44]

I'd do the Tkachuk one.

no chance calgary does. doubt they do the Johnny and Bennett one

 

[BB88]

Minny and Florida proposals aren’t even close in value.

Not a damm chance Florida trades a 90 point winger for 90 point winger, and add a lot

 

[The Winter Soldier]

You're only going to get quantity for Marner; that cap hit is a killer...

10.9 on a dead cap is going to be tough to move if you want fair return, Dubas really handcuffed himself with that contract overpayment. Not that I think Marner is being shopped, I don't think he is. But if he was, the contract is going will lessen his return.

 

[MakeCgyGreatAgain]

Holy crap it started with one bad proposal and then added a whole lot more. You’re a Leafs fan we get it.

 

[Volica]

Tor-Cgy
To Toronto:
Tkachuk

To Calgary:
Marner

OR
To Toronto:
Gaudreau
Bennett

To Calgary:
Marner

1st one no thanks.
Second one... we would need the cap to work because we’re taking on an extra 2+ million in cap in that deal. Toronto can either retain a million or, more likely, one of the contracts Calgary has would have to go the other way. Maybe a retained Doc Ryan.

 

[Volica]

I'd do the Tkachuk one.

Flames fans would not.

 

[Laus723]

Lol...no.

 

[SensFactor]

Ottawa:
Marner

Toronto:
1st 2021 (top 3 protected)
2nd 2021
Brannstrom
Drake Batherson

 

[hockeeyyy]

Ottawa:
Marner

Toronto:
1st 2021 (top 5 protected)
2nd 2021
Brannstrom
Drake Batherson

That lottery protection is adorable.

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Good thing you'd added Tippett in the deal to balance what a downgrade Hubs is from an $11 million Marner.

 

[SensFactor]

That lottery protection is adorable.

Updated

 

[Skinnyjimmy08]

I stopped reading after the absurd Huberdeau one lol

 

[Dr Danglefest]

Tor - Fla
To Toronto:
Huberdeau
Weegar
Tippett

To Florida:
Marner
Dermott

Tor-Min
To Toronto:
Eriksson Ek
Greenway
Dumba

To Minny:
Marner
Dermott

Tor-Cgy
To Toronto:
Tkachuk

To Calgary:
Marner

OR
To Toronto:
Gaudreau
Bennett

To Calgary:
Marner

Trade 1
Huberdeau > Marner ever so slightly
Weegar > Dermott
Tippett >> nothing
FLA SAYS NO

Trade 2
I’d Say Minny actually strongly considers, I get that JEE is looking like a Jordan Staal type and Greenway has potential but I’d still take the top line forward and the downgrade at D where they are deeper
MAYBE?

Trade 3
wash value wise, Tkachuk probably brings more versatility and why make a trade for the sake of making a trade plus he’s going to come cheaper contract wise
CGY SAYS NO

TRADE 4
Makes no sense for Toronto
TOR SAYS NO