Ace Card Bedard
Back in Black, Red, and White
- Feb 11, 2012
- 8,793
- 3,649
Underrated player throughout his whole career.
how highly should he be rated?
all the great teams he played on, was he ever better than 3rd or 4th best on his own team?
2008 penguins - crosby, malkin, hossa
2009 wings - datsyuk, zetterberg, lidstrom, hossa
blackhawks - toews , kane, keith, hossa
this is exactly why I have never been too high on Hossa. He's had a long career, played a lot of games, scored a lot of points. But on the teams he's been on and had some success he's been a 3rd or 4th fiddle kind of guy. His time in Ottawa and Atlanta where he was a top end player, he never got it done.
He has HOF numbers no doubt but he accumulated most of that with the opposition more focused on those other big names you've listed
this is exactly why I have never been too high on Hossa. He's had a long career, played a lot of games, scored a lot of points. But on the teams he's been on and had some success he's been a 3rd or 4th fiddle kind of guy. His time in Ottawa and Atlanta where he was a top end player, he never got it done.
He has HOF numbers no doubt but he accumulated most of that with the opposition more focused on those other big names you've listed
this is exactly why I have never been too high on Hossa. He's had a long career, played a lot of games, scored a lot of points. But on the teams he's been on and had some success he's been a 3rd or 4th fiddle kind of guy. His time in Ottawa and Atlanta where he was a top end player, he never got it done.
He has HOF numbers no doubt but he accumulated most of that with the opposition more focused on those other big names you've listed
this is exactly why I have never been too high on Hossa. He's had a long career, played a lot of games, scored a lot of points. But on the teams he's been on and had some success he's been a 3rd or 4th fiddle kind of guy. His time in Ottawa and Atlanta where he was a top end player, he never got it done.
He has HOF numbers no doubt but he accumulated most of that with the opposition more focused on those other big names you've listed
Nonsense. You're knocking a future 1000pt, 500 goal, HoFer because he is/was not the best player on teams that had generatational, franchise, and other HoF players on it.
So you're faulting him for never being able to carry a garbage team to the championship?
i don't think alfredsson, chara, redden, havlat, young spezza, and a bunch of other guys (fisher, vermette, todd white, phillips, young a-train, schaefer, bonk, bondra, smolinski...) was a garbage team
this is exactly why I have never been too high on Hossa. He's had a long career, played a lot of games, scored a lot of points. But on the teams he's been on and had some success he's been a 3rd or 4th fiddle kind of guy. His time in Ottawa and Atlanta where he was a top end player, he never got it done.
He has HOF numbers no doubt but he accumulated most of that with the opposition more focused on those other big names you've listed
every full season hossa played for Ottawa, they made the playoffs. 3 division titles. Lead the team in scoring in both the regular season and playoffs en route to a game 7 conference final loss in 2003. This was a team that played Curtis Leschyshyn in all 18 of their playoff games. Alfredsson was a no-show that post season. only 8 points in 18 playoff games. Fisher with only 4 points. Hossa put that team on his back as a 24 year old and got them to within 1 win of a SCF.
i don't think alfredsson, chara, redden, havlat, young spezza, and a bunch of other guys (fisher, vermette, todd white, phillips, young a-train, schaefer, bonk, bondra, smolinski...) was a garbage team
Well, he cheers for the Flyers, so clearly he knows what a garbage team looks like.
Try reading the original post I responded to again...
on the teams he's been on and had some success he's been a 3rd or 4th fiddle kind of guy. His time in Ottawa and Atlanta where he was a top end player, he never got it done.
So you're faulting him for never being able to carry a garbage team to the championship?
i don't think alfredsson, chara, redden, havlat, young spezza, and a bunch of other guys (fisher, vermette, todd white, phillips, young a-train, schaefer, bonk, bondra, smolinski...) was a garbage team
I don't understand what the problem is about being 3 or 4 on a great team. Jari Kurri comes to mind. He's in the Hall and in his time in Edmonton, he was always behind Gretzky and Messier and potentially Coffey.
I don't understand what the problem is about being 3 or 4 on a great team. Jari Kurri comes to mind. He's in the Hall and in his time in Edmonton, he was always behind Gretzky and Messier and potentially Coffey.
Kurri at times was the 2nd best Oiler. As was Coffey. As was Messier. Just saying Kurri was not always behind a younger Messier ot later Edmonton Coffey for the dynasty Oilers. Messier was inconsistent when younger.
And the same thing is true of Hossa. He was right on par with Malkin and Crosby in the playoffs for Pittsburgh in the finals run he had there. Might have been the best of the 3. Hossa was also at times the best Senator over Alfredsson or Chara or anyone else.
Hossa might have been the 3rd/4th/5th best player at times on great teams in Detroit and Chicago. But at some moments he was their best player. Led Detroit in goals.
People forget that Hossa's absolute peak were his last years in Ottawa and the often forgotten years in Atlanta. He was 29 years old in Pittsburgh for that short run. 30 in Detroit. 31 to start in Chicago. For Hossa to be a core player in Chicago all this time, but behind Kane, Toews and Keith is nothing to sneeze at for the second half of a career.
Hossa is always an invaluable player every game, even if his scoring is not at it's highest level.