Apotheosis
Registered User
Nielsen will be playing with the Leafs either next season or the year after. His development trajectory has been insane.
Yea Nielsen is nothing like Percy. Both play different games.
Really both have poor foot work....that is a huge issue.
I mention this about Percy back in the day and everyone stated that Barb can fix it....but she can't and that is an issue.
I stated that Nielson has more skill and that is true. I sure hope that he can improve his foot work enough to be an NHL player.
To add same as Finn, everyone on here had him playing top pair when he was playing in the OHL and he was steal at the draft, I stated that we drafted him to high for the same reason....bad feet.
Really both have poor foot work....that is a huge issue.
I mention this about Percy back in the day and everyone stated that Barb can fix it....but she can't and that is an issue.
I stated that Nielson has more skill and that is true. I sure hope that he can improve his foot work enough to be an NHL player.
To add same as Finn, everyone on here had him playing top pair when he was playing in the OHL and he was steal at the draft, I stated that we drafted him to high for the same reason....bad feet.
Nielson is absolutely NOWHERE near being as bad of a skater as Finn was. Finn was an absolute pathetic skater.
Nielsen can get turned around, so agility and first 1-2 strides are a concern.
Hopefully Barb puts in some good time with him, 2-3 years in the minors was always the expectation before he came up imo, we already have a young blueline as it is.
Nielson is absolutely NOWHERE near being as bad of a skater as Finn was. Finn was an absolute pathetic skater.
I agree he is better skater then Finn, and so was Percy, but bad feet prevents many from playing in the NHL and if they do make it, lets hope he is one of the exceptions, as like the other parts of his game.
To add to this, Nielsen isn't even a bad skater, he's just not an elite skater.
I liked the nielsen the day we drafts him. Thought he could he a 3rd pairing defender with a big shot Right now he's one of our elite prospects. Every time I watch him play he's amazing. I honestly think in 3 years he's the leafs best overall defensemen. He just ends to fix his skating a little. He's got great skills everywhere else. Wouldn't trade him, kappy, and leipsic from he current Marlies team.
Who else isn't an elite skater: Ryan Suter.
I've seen Nielsen live 4 times this season not including the rookie tournament. His point production is great but what excites me the most is his IQ and vision. I always get the impression that he's 2 steps ahead of the play. It's hard to explain but I'm left feeling like he already knows what he's going to do before the play gets to him and has a contingency if something changes. There is no panic.
His skating, most specifically his first 2 steps, needs work but his smarts and reach compensate well at this level. If he can improve in this regard the sky is the limit IMHO.
Ryan Suter is not at all a bad skater, his foot worker is great but not pretty. I am not talking about style or speed but foot work. Ryan Suter is not at all real fast but his foot work allows him to play at a Elite Level in the NHL.. He uses quick changes of direction...(Foot work ) as a tool to enable him to make those quick passes.
Wouldn't that fall under edge work? also I've heard Neilsen is pretty decent with his edges.
Neilson is pretty decent when it comes to edge control. He's got good balance, but doesn't build momentum efficiently. While it's obvious that one doesn't need to be McDavid with his pristine stride, being able to quickly change directions is essential for a defenseman.Wouldn't that fall under edge work? also I've heard Neilsen is pretty decent with his edges.
Never is the correct answer.
He has some great skills, but skating is the great equalizer....He is a similar to Percy but with more offense skill, he has improved in all areas over the last 3 years and if he can continue then he may make the NHL at some point. I was struck by his unforced mistakes as this is a sign that the game is to fast for him. Fingers crossed that he can continue his progress and develop into an NHL player who will use his big body.
Didn't you say the same thing about Marner. I think you called him chicken legs too. Was that you I'm not really sure but i know you have this propensity for rating skating as a precursor for how good you rank a player.
Didn't you say the same thing about Marner. I think you called him chicken legs too. Was that you I'm not really sure but i know you have this propensity for rating skating as a precursor for how good you rank a player.
It is his transitional skating that is an issue and it is the hardest to improve...bad feet is not an item that Barb or any skating instructor can fix, if so Finn and Percy would be in the NHL right now.
I like his game....tough and great shot, good reach. Good work ethic. I sure hope I am wrong here.
a good comp might be bryan mccabe, actually. big mobile guy with a poor first step / turn.
Nope I said he was an elite skater.....It was Mike etc that was attacking his skating. I called Marner our Franchise player last year. I was one of the few that stated his skating was not an issue.
As for ranking players, skating is the single most important skill when ranking players.