If Leafs show no improvement in the playoffs and still allow 3 goals a game on average, coaching should definitely be looked at.
Everything is looked at at the end of every season for every team.
I don't understand why people insist on pointing a crooked finger towards the coaching staff and say, yeah that is the problem. When this coaching staff is leading a team that was on a franchise record setting pace, players who play in this environment are setting individual team records. The team has the 2nd best GF/GA differential in the league but people default to blame the coaches. There is no thought that the personnel might not be ready to win, might not have the right chemistry on the team, we might be facing a better team, I know its shocking but there are teams that are considerably better than the Leafs.
How about we do this we ask ourselves are the players learning and growing as individuals and as teammates? Is the team top 10 in the league? Are we developing players on the Marlies who can help the big team? Is the GM actively looking for areas to improve? Does the coaching staff still have the ability to affect change?
Win or lose in round one this year, that is immaterial to the long term growth of this team, it's not about this year, it never has been. It took Ovi something like 14 years to win a cup, it took Sid on a veteran laden team 4 or 5 years to win a cup. We may make all the right moves and never win the Cup.
Enjoy the ride and the maturation process of all these great young talents are going through, you have to pay your dues before they will let you into the champions club. There is nothing that I see in this years team that suggests to me that they are ready to be a champion or have learned the lessons a champion must learn before they become a champion.