I can't believe we're discussing the Leafs chances of making the playoffs. It should have been a slam dunk from the onset of the season (no, coaching is not an excuse).
It is when the team has started playing much better under the new coach early on, and should only get better as time goes on. If we had Keefe's record from the start of the year, we'd be in second place in our division right now and would be around as good as PIT, CAR and PHI
What we need is a Buffalo, Philly or Calgary-like run. One where we have a nice point streak. We play EDM, BUF, NYR, DET, CAR, NJD, NYR, and MIN to close out the year. If we didn't make so many mistakes, we could easily win all of those games, however this team is still making far too many (as you can see from last night).
So lets say we can get the wins against MIN, NJD and DET , because I think we can still win those games even if we make mistakes and have Hutch in net for at least 2 of them. Then if we can just muster 3/5 wins against EDM, NYR x 2, CAR and BUF (especially against BUF), we would be 8-3-0 in the last 11 games of 2019 and would have 46 points in 41 games (so on pace for 92). Obviously we'd need to play a lot better in the 2nd half than in the 1st half of the year, but the Leafs would have a 12-6-0 record under Keefe, they'd have everyone healthy, and I believe they'll have an easier schedule too... And if the landscape generally stays the same, it's not like their competition would be on pace for much better.
However if the Leafs can't get it done in the rest of December, or mess up in January, we are done and we are sellers at the end of January. The next month and a half have to be at least at the Keefe-like pace (.600) for us to even have a chance of staying in the race.