Finally got around to The Shape of Water 9/10
What I find so remarkable about this movie is how strange the concept is on its face...borderline perverse...but Del Toro makes a near masterpiece out of it. To call it less than a masterful work of cinematic art is to do it a disservice, however I do think a few elements keep it out of masterpiece territory.
So I'll address those cons right off the bat. First of all, I appreciate a movie that can deliver social messages. Don't get me wrong. But for all the movie's strengths in conveying themes of loneliness, finding solace in the solidarity between two misunderstood characters, love, and devotion through very subtle and emotive channels...I thought the moments where the movie tried to touch on issues of homophobia, racism, and sexism to be lacking subtlety and felt quite shoehorned. The implementation of these themes just felt so juxtaposed to the way the core themes were handled in a way that kind of makes for a slightly jarring experience where I felt there was true artistry in how the core themes were handled.
Then, I felt...while Micheal Shannon's performance was strong and quite imposing, there were times he felt a bit like a caricature. His motivations and drives were believable but there were some moments that did feel kind of mustache twirling villain for me.
Everything else was phenomenal though. The acting, cinematography, score, soundtrack, story telling. I felt fortunate to have given my time to watch this film and I'm sure I'll be watching it again before its HBO circulation ends.
What I find so remarkable about this movie is how strange the concept is on its face...borderline perverse...but Del Toro makes a near masterpiece out of it. To call it less than a masterful work of cinematic art is to do it a disservice, however I do think a few elements keep it out of masterpiece territory.
So I'll address those cons right off the bat. First of all, I appreciate a movie that can deliver social messages. Don't get me wrong. But for all the movie's strengths in conveying themes of loneliness, finding solace in the solidarity between two misunderstood characters, love, and devotion through very subtle and emotive channels...I thought the moments where the movie tried to touch on issues of homophobia, racism, and sexism to be lacking subtlety and felt quite shoehorned. The implementation of these themes just felt so juxtaposed to the way the core themes were handled in a way that kind of makes for a slightly jarring experience where I felt there was true artistry in how the core themes were handled.
Then, I felt...while Micheal Shannon's performance was strong and quite imposing, there were times he felt a bit like a caricature. His motivations and drives were believable but there were some moments that did feel kind of mustache twirling villain for me.
Everything else was phenomenal though. The acting, cinematography, score, soundtrack, story telling. I felt fortunate to have given my time to watch this film and I'm sure I'll be watching it again before its HBO circulation ends.