Last Concert You Saw and Rate It

Wee Baby Seamus

Yo, Goober, where's the meat?
Mar 15, 2011
15,010
5,970
Halifax/Toronto
Arcade Fire/Broken Social Scene - Air Canada Centre - 3 November 2017

Arcade Fire was my formative band. Funeral has been my favourite album since I was 13 and will almost certainly remain as such forever; even if I find albums that are objectively better, that album will always have such huge significance for me. However, I entered this show with decently low expectations. Everything Now is garbage, and my friend who I was going with had to cancel last minute, so I wasn't that pumped going into it. Honestly, I was more excited for Broken Social Scene (who I had never seen before) than I was for Arcade Fire.

BSS went on at around 8:30, and, much to my disappointment (and I'm sure theirs as well), the stadium was pretty much empty when they started. Their set was great and sounded great, but the enormity of the ACC combined with the scattering of people throughout the building meant that the vibe was really weird and distant, and kinda just bummed me out. Feist came and performed with them, which was absolutely awesome, but Emily Haines wasn't there, so they didn't play a bunch of the classics they've been playing the entire tour (for instance, no "Anthem for a Seventeen Year Old Girl." Definitely still a lot of fun, but only 45 minutes of Broken Social Scene in such a strange venue was a bit of a bummer. I hope they play another Toronto show soon in a much better location.

Until Arcade Fire literally started playing, I was expecting their set to be absolutely brutal. In between BSS and their set, there was a lot of obnoxious annoying shit on the Jumbotron with the type of beat-ya-over-the-head edgy Banksy satire that Everything Now is all about, and I was really worried that the Arcade Fire set would be Win Butler up-his-own-ass for 90 minutes.

I should've had more faith. "Everything Now" (the song) provided for a pretty bumping opener, and the energy was high and just buzzing. There was no obnoxious Win Butler commentary, just a fun vibrant show. Even the mediocrity of Everything Now was pretty decent live, and they thankfully did not play any of the pure unmitigatable crap from that album. The setlist was strange. They played just as much from Neon Bible as they did from The Suburbs and Reflektor (which I don't mind at all, I think Neon Bible is far better than Reflektor is). The important thing, though, is that Arcade Fire are just complete performers. They're so exciting live because they fully immerse themselves and just go absolutely insane into the music. I should've had more faith that Arcade Fire's capacity for performing would outweigh the mediocrity of the new album.
 

Porn*

Registered User
Mar 6, 2002
36,386
5
In your nightmares
Oct 30th: Guns N Roses
Great experience considering that this is probably the last opportunity to see them live.
Intro
(Introduction Presentation, (Halloween Intro))
It's So Easy
Mr. Brownstone
Chinese Democracy
Welcome to the Jungle
Double Talkin' Jive
Better
Estranged
Live and Let Die
(Wings cover)
Rocket Queen
You Could Be Mine
Attitude
(Misfits cover)
This I Love
There Was a Time
Civil War
Yesterdays
Coma
(Axl introduces the band)
Slash Guitar Solo
Speak Softly Love (Love Theme From The Godfather)
(Nino Rota cover)
Sweet Child O' Mine
Wichita Lineman
(Jimmy Webb cover)
Used to Love Her
My Michelle
Wish You Were Here
(Pink Floyd cover) (Slash & Richard Fortus guitar duet)
November Rain
("Layla" by Derek and the… more )
Black Hole Sun
(Soundgarden cover)
Knockin' on Heaven's Door
(Bob Dylan cover) (with "Only Women Bleed "intro)
Nightrain
Encore:
Sorry
Don't Cry
Patience
(With "Melissa" Intro)
Madagascar
The Seeker
(The Who cover)
Paradise City
*****
Highlights:
Slash (insane talent)
Nighttrain
Attitude Cover
Civil War
The Hits...
Mr. Brownstone
Patience
Axl nearly tripping on stage (no obstructions in sight)
Lowlights:
Axl Rose (voice was horrendous for the most part)
The Seeker and Black Hole Sun were both BUTCHERED.
I was hoping for Sympathy for the Devil.
Drums were hardly noticeable.
Chinese democracy
 

irishsetter13

Registered User
Jan 24, 2016
482
254
Just saw Thrice and Circa Survive last Friday Night in LA.

Circa Surive was really good live. Good energy. Definitely would see them again. 8/10.

Thrice was amazing as always. Ive seen them so many times but they always blow my mind. Their set started hard but ended on a much soft note than usual. But it was still awesome. 10/10.
 

zac

Registered User
Apr 29, 2009
8,484
42
I go to a lot of shows. The last show I saw was King Krule in Minneapolis. Venue was a 6-7 and Krule was fantastic, likely between an 8 and a 9. My favorites from the year are McCartney, Paul Simon, Depeche Mode, Soundgarden (2nd to last show before his death), Stapleton, RCHP, Roosevelt, Tank and the Bangas, Rainbow Kitten Surprise (3 x), Bryan Ferry, and Vulfpeck. LCD Soundsystem was also bad ass.

Colorado: Paul Simon at Red Rocks, Cut Copy in Aspen, Depeche Mode at Pepsi Center.
Iowa: Lake Street Dive and Local Natives at Woolys, Hall and Oates Iowa Events Center, the Cults at Vaudeville Mews (all in Des Moines) and 2 Cellos at a small amph in Cedar Rapids
Philly: Roosevelt at the Foundry. Kick ass venue
New York: Governor's Ball and Roosevelt in Brooklyn
Atanta: LCD Soundsystem
StL: Sting at the Pageant, Sir Sly at the Duck Room, Chicano Batman at Firebird, Rainbow Kitten Surprise at OffBroadway
Omaha: Lumineers at CenturyLink, Spoon at the Sokol (POS venue)
Minneapolis: King Krule at Fine Line, and Vulfpeck at First Avenue
Columbia, MO: Stapleton at Mizzou arena and the Revivalists at the Blue Note
KC/Lawrence (hometown): RHCP, Mayer, Gorillaz, Weeknd, Coldplay, and Radiohead at Sprint Center. Muse, Soundgarden, The 1975, The XX, APC, Cold War Kids (YTG was rained out),and Alt-J at Starlight Amph (hands down one of the best venues in the country). Tank and the Bangas, RKS, and several more at the Record Bar. Garbage/Blondie, George Benson, and Yes at Kauffman. Arcade Fire at Silverstein. Bryan Ferry, B52s, SZA, and Thorogood at the Uptown. Fleet Foxes, City and Colour, Two Door Cinema Club, Run the Jewels, and Kaleo at the Midland. Father John, Atlas Genius, Lake Street Dive, St Paul and the Broken Bones, and Queens of the Stone Age at Crossroads. Saint Motel and a few others at Boulevardia. Buzz Beach Ball with Iron Tom, the Toadies, Foster the People, etc in Bonner. Several shows in Lawrence, including RKS, Deerhunter, Blind Pilot, Thundercat, and little Dragon. There is a lot more I'm sure I'm forgetting.

Coming up is St Vincent, Death From Above, Cut Copy, Tyler the Creator before I go to India. Might catch Perfume Genius in New York when I fly back. Then Greta Van Fleet back in Lawrence in December.
 

BonMorrison

Registered User
Jun 17, 2011
33,710
9,538
Toronto, ON
Aaron West and the Roaring Twenties - 8/10

Great show. Dan Campbell stayed in character the entire time and made the whole thing an emotional rollercoaster. Crowd was super into it as well.
 

Sleemans

Sleep Well Beast
Oct 4, 2003
1,328
30
Kingston,Ontario
Visit site
Arcade Fire/Broken Social Scene - Air Canada Centre - 3 November 2017

I was at the November 4th show, and agree with pretty much everything you said above.

I also don't like the new AF album, and was less pumped to see the concert. BSS were great, and I would have liked to see them play longer. AF put on a fantastic show, and I really liked anything they played off their first 3 albums. However even the new material sounded better live.

Coming up next .. The National Dec. 9th.
 

Wee Baby Seamus

Yo, Goober, where's the meat?
Mar 15, 2011
15,010
5,970
Halifax/Toronto
I was at the November 4th show, and agree with pretty much everything you said above.

I also don't like the new AF album, and was less pumped to see the concert. BSS were great, and I would have liked to see them play longer. AF put on a fantastic show, and I really liked anything they played off their first 3 albums. However even the new material sounded better live.

Coming up next .. The National Dec. 9th.

I'm at The National too! I also have Kamasi Washington and Andy Shauf in between.
 

HFBS

Noted Troublemaker
Jan 18, 2015
2,134
2,108
I don't know if it would considered a concert here but the last show I saw was Bruce Springsteen on Broadway. Simply amazing. Bruce, acoustic guitar, and piano. That's it. Telling his life story through words and music.

This year I've also seen Eric Clapton, the Classic East Show which was the Doobie Brothers, Steely Dan, the Eagles, Earth Wind & Fire, Journey and Fleetwood Mac. Plus Paul McCartney of course.

Obviously don't know most of the bands the rest of you saw.
 

Desdichado93

Registered User
Jan 7, 2012
1,292
246
Sweden
I was at a small gig yesterday. It was a Swedish band called Baskery who performed at a smaller venue called Biografbaren.
It's basically a bar (obviously) which have gigs in their basement. It's quite small and capacity isn't more then maybe 100 people but it's a great little cosy place with the band/artist are put in a stage less corner
of the room with some chairs, tables, a bar and a sofa are scattered around the room (except for the sofa).

Baskery is a band that I have been following for over 10 years and this was the third time that I saw them live.
Their music isn't easy to put into a specific genre since they more or less have their own genre.
They play sort of "Nordicana", "Mud country", "Banjo punk", like altenate country/Blues/bluegrass
with some influences from rock and pop.

Their set up is all three sister on vocals, eldest sister Greta on banjo and bass drum,
middle sister Stella on double bass and youngest sister Sunniva on guitar.
All instruments are amplified one way or another.

The concert was superb. 5+ on 1-5 scale. It was a really intense and pretty loud gig.
They play very good but the three sibling harmonies is just wow. If you are into this kind of music
and you have the chance to see them live, take it!.

A few clips:
Bort all vad oro gör (Swedish drinking song from the 18 century, written by Carl Michael Bellman)


Tendencies (not the full song, only a 50 sec clip)


One Horse Down.
 

Hippasus

1,9,45,165,495,1287,
Feb 17, 2008
5,616
346
Bridgeview
Several weeks ago I saw Armored Assault (375), Kaustik (400), and D.R.I. (425). Ratings are in parentheses. Armored Assault were sort of catchy, in addition to Kaustik. The interplay between the bass and guitar was impressive, especially for a sort-of crossover punk show. The bassist in Armored Assault was especially talented with his fretwork. Kaustik was balls-to-the-wall and aggressive punk that almost sounded metalcore-ish. It was okay and very intense. D.R.I. delivered even more in that regard. For me, the whole show was like a D.R.I. appreciation night. They were arguably the inventors of the blast beat and this was very important for hardcore, crossover, thrash, black metal, grindcore, and death metal. They played a good amount of their mid- to later-era material. I was not the biggest fan of this stuff when I heard it on the albums, but these songs sounded much better to me when performed live. I think it might have been because they sounded more raw and unproduced in a live setting.

200: distasteful and pathetic
300: mediocre or subpar
400: average, but decent
500: very good
600: superb
700: transcendental
 

Bubba Thudd

is getting banned
Jul 19, 2005
24,571
4,666
Avaland
I saw the Texas Hippie Coalition on Dec 30.
Some of my concert buddies know the band, so we all pitched in and threw a BBQ before the show.
Grilled burgers, dogs, and brats. Tater salad, chips, etc.
Got into the (small, local) venue 2 hours early for this.
Got our grub on with all bands on the bill, the venue employees, and about 30 members of the Texas Hippie Coalition "Family" (which I was adopted into this time)
Seen them 3 times now, and they're always a good show.
Texas rock meets metal.
Not quite as heavy metal as Pantera, but a lot heavier than most Texas/Southern rock.

8/10
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ozz

Ozz

Registered User
Oct 25, 2009
9,468
682
Hockeytown
Black Label Society for the umteenth time.

Won't bother to rate it since it's arbitrary and my feelings change with the wind, but the night itself was one for the ages.

A friend traveled in to celebrate my birthday that weekend and go to the show with me; for he and I Zakk is the king. We've met and hung out with him numerous times over the years, the first being 18 years ago. We rarely planned to meet him but this time we did with the VIP package, so I printed out copies of our pic from 18 years ago to get signed.

Thanks to the snow my friend was unable to arrive in time so I brought my other best friend to the VIP thing. He rarely gets out to a concert so we had a blast, then the other guy arrived JUST at showtime. Instead of his direct flight, he flew halfway and drove the rest. Insane. The buildup through the day for his arrival was just ensuring we'd go nuts once he finally did. The stories...I can't even...

ANYWAY we had some good hangs w/Zakk and the band, they loved the very old picture, we got extra time to talk w/them thanks to it and the obvious history, and he even recorded a hello video for my 3 year old son who is a big fan as far as a 3 y/o can be. He loves watching it over and over.

The show itself was great as always; anyone familiar w/Zakk knows he is a showman and a half. I've seen them so many times they shows mostly blend together, and while it wasn't as jaw-dropping as last year's Zakk Sabbath show (his Black Sabbath tribute band where he spends half the show playing in the middle of the crowd) it was still an awesome performance. He said earlier in the night that he was sick (has since canceled 4 shows following ours), though you couldn't really tell. The vocals were mixed a little lower than usual but I see that w/many bands anyway and by that comparison it was a non-issue.

Lastly, I got to meet and talk to Darren McCarty for about half an hour as well! What a cool guy. We met through a mutual acquaintance who just happened to be telling him a story about me from years ago, right before I walked up and said hi. That was when he points to Mac in disbelief, saying he was just talking about it. That set us off for the night and away we rolled.
 

Porn*

Registered User
Mar 6, 2002
36,386
5
In your nightmares
Anyone seen the Foo Fighters lately? I'm seeing them in July and i'm pretty stoked. Dave Grohl came out during the Prophets of Rage concert in Toronto a few years back which was very cool.
 

kook10

Registered User
Jun 27, 2011
4,723
2,829
Miranda Lambert @ The Forum 8.75 /10

Very good set and show, albeit a little on the short side and with a couple "human" vocal moments. I don't love the sound in arenas, but the crowd was one of the loudest I've heard. Her performance of Tin Man was exceptional.
 

Peter Zezel

Registered User
Sep 12, 2003
983
31
Arcade Fire/Broken Social Scene - Air Canada Centre - 3 November 2017

Arcade Fire was my formative band. Funeral has been my favourite album since I was 13 and will almost certainly remain as such forever; even if I find albums that are objectively better, that album will always have such huge significance for me. However, I entered this show with decently low expectations. Everything Now is garbage, and my friend who I was going with had to cancel last minute, so I wasn't that pumped going into it. Honestly, I was more excited for Broken Social Scene (who I had never seen before) than I was for Arcade Fire.

BSS went on at around 8:30, and, much to my disappointment (and I'm sure theirs as well), the stadium was pretty much empty when they started. Their set was great and sounded great, but the enormity of the ACC combined with the scattering of people throughout the building meant that the vibe was really weird and distant, and kinda just bummed me out. Feist came and performed with them, which was absolutely awesome, but Emily Haines wasn't there, so they didn't play a bunch of the classics they've been playing the entire tour (for instance, no "Anthem for a Seventeen Year Old Girl." Definitely still a lot of fun, but only 45 minutes of Broken Social Scene in such a strange venue was a bit of a bummer. I hope they play another Toronto show soon in a much better location.

Until Arcade Fire literally started playing, I was expecting their set to be absolutely brutal. In between BSS and their set, there was a lot of obnoxious annoying **** on the Jumbotron with the type of beat-ya-over-the-head edgy Banksy satire that Everything Now is all about, and I was really worried that the Arcade Fire set would be Win Butler up-his-own-ass for 90 minutes.

I should've had more faith. "Everything Now" (the song) provided for a pretty bumping opener, and the energy was high and just buzzing. There was no obnoxious Win Butler commentary, just a fun vibrant show. Even the mediocrity of Everything Now was pretty decent live, and they thankfully did not play any of the pure unmitigatable crap from that album. The setlist was strange. They played just as much from Neon Bible as they did from The Suburbs and Reflektor (which I don't mind at all, I think Neon Bible is far better than Reflektor is). The important thing, though, is that Arcade Fire are just complete performers. They're so exciting live because they fully immerse themselves and just go absolutely insane into the music. I should've had more faith that Arcade Fire's capacity for performing would outweigh the mediocrity of the new album.
I saw Arcade Fire play Calgary in October and it also made me like Everything Now more. It's probably my least favourite of their albums, but I get the vibe they were going for after seeing them live.

BSS did a show in Calgary this past October at a smaller venue. It was awesome, but it was also the day after Gord Downie past away. They played Gord's favourite BSS song Lover's Spit and ended the concert with Anthem for a Seventeen Year Old Girl. It was pretty rad how everyone was singing park that car, drop that phone, sleep on the floor, dream about me.

Kevin Drew jumped off the stage, came into the crowd and started hugging people. He also had a therapeutic scream pause where we all screamed Gord's name. They did have a few feedback issues with the sound, but the band sounded really good aside from a few times. It was my first time seeing BSS and I hope it's not the last. It was a really great, emotional show.
 

Hippasus

1,9,45,165,495,1287,
Feb 17, 2008
5,616
346
Bridgeview
I saw Nunslaughter last Saturday. They are 80s metal. They are thrashy, proto-death metal one could say. I rate it 400. I think they've had some lineup changes. Notably, the percussion player, Jim, passed away not too long ago. When I saw them a few years ago at a metal fest in Calgary (Noctis), it was one of the best sets I'd been to, and still is. So this was a bit of a disappointment. The vocals seemed a little weaker, and the musicianship wasn't as on-point and emphatic as I recalled them being the last time around. Particularly the guitars and percussion. Still, I'm glad I caught a band I really like this past weekend.

200: distasteful and pathetic
300: mediocre or subpar
400: average, but decent
500: very good
600: superb
700: transcendental

EDIT: I also caught a portion of the set from a band called Cardiac Arrest. They were okay (decent bass and vocals), but I think the riffs lacked expansiveness and-or structure. The vocalist also made some remark about wanting propaganda out of metal. Not sure what he was talking about, but I was wearing a Darkthrone shirt and if he was talking about black metal, I think he's off-base. Since I didn't see a portion of their set, I will refrain from rating it.
 
Last edited:

BonMorrison

Registered User
Jun 17, 2011
33,710
9,538
Toronto, ON
Dashboard Confessional - 7/10
Mura Masa - 6/10
Brian Fallon - 9/10
Carpenter Brut - 10/10
Protest the Hero - 8/10
f***ed Up - 8/10

Concert season is upon us.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad