Guerin will likely take flak for the one year deal but at the time they said he Fiala needed to show he had the all around game to be worthy, prior to this year he hadn’t shown enough consistency or defensive acumen to be a long term commitment. He has taken massive steps forward in both regards this year, probably motivated by those comments and contract action. He said himself that playing on the PK was really huge for developing and maintaining proper defensive positioning and reads, over the last half season that has paid huge dividends in his all around play. He won’t compete for Selkes but he is vastly improved and his D play is now leading to more offensive opportunities through turnovers and rushes.
That 1 year deal may cost MN the player but I think it helped him become a far superior hockey player than he was, and Fiala is better for it. He is worth more than we can reasonably pay him, it would take a sweet heart signing to keep him, or he will be worth a haul in a trade. The team acquiring him will be getting a very good hockey player, capable of bringing fans to their feet every game with his dazzling talents and ability to break a game open.