I think this is a move you make post-expansion draft since we're most likely going to be protecting Campbell. I think a summer deal for Gibson would be nice and I would happily throw them a couple of firsts and some mid-tier prospects. I would try my best to save Lilly/Sandin, Robertson/ Amirov. After that everyone is fair game. Only reason I don't want to give up on those 4 kids is that they're all on their ELC and pretty good NHL ready players and we're going to need them to slot in for cheap for the next 3-5 years until our cap situation improves.
I would love to see something like;
To Tor:
John Gibson
To Anaheim:
2021 1st round pick
2021 2nd round pick
2022 1st round pick
B prospect
It's a ton to give up but Gibson has 6 years left after this? And he's been an absolute star playing in front of a tire fire team.
Well that is not far off from Andersen + Dermott/Engvall + prospect + 1st. Andersen would have to get flipped of course.
Also Anaheim mostly can't score right now. Defensively they are performing similarly to the Leafs, which is not the greatest right now, but Andersen perpetuates it a fair bit right now. Gibson is doing worse at ES save percentage, but is doing a fair bit better with high danger save percentage. The Leafs are also doing a good job at preventing rebound chances, whereas Anaheim gives up a ton, so that is even better for a guy like Gibson.
Andersen is mostly just doing about as well as the team in front of him at ES, but doesn't really steal anything. That has helped us win a lot because the team in front of him has mostly been really good, although can be better. Gibson is not significantly better than Andersen at ES (he is doing a little bit better than his defense right now) but he is also doing better with his rebound control so he is making it easier on his defense than Andersen is right now.
The main difference between Gibson and Andersen right now is PK. Andersen is arguably the worst starter in the league at PK, despite our PK being top 5-10 in terms of the vast majority of defensive metrics. Gibson is one of the best by far despite Anaheim's PK being bottom 10 in most metrics.