what team have u been watching this year? cause if u think gilbert has been the best defenseman u havent been watching the oilers...
i don't even know what say about this statement, you can't be serious... Gilbert has been horrible this year, beyond horrible, the minnesota game he stopped skating on what he thought was an icing, then when he realized it wasn't icing he panicked, tripped and minnesota scored, he doesn't hit, and gets pushed off the puck by basically any forward with a pulse, but yeah he's been great...
seriously, i would really like to hear how u think he's even in the conversation of being better than whitney, peckham, petry or even vandemeer for that matter... the oilers defense sucks, and gilbert has been the worst of the bunch thus far, it's a shame because he ended last year playing pretty well...