Who would have guessed that 3 out of the top 5 would bust in that draft class and that Draisaitl was the one who didn't
I wouldn't call Sam Reinhart a bust. He had 25 goals, 50 points last season. Although that isn't exactly high-end production, that's far from bust territory. Throughout his career, he has been a ~20 goal, ~45 point player while averaging 17 minutes per game.
His points-per-game average of 0.58 and goals-per-game of 0.27 over the last three seasons are very comparable to Bo Horvat's 0.60 points-per-game and 0.26 goals-per-game averages from 2015-16 to 2017-18. Bo has averaged 18 minutes per game in that time frame.
However, Bo is on an upward trajectory, whereas Reinhart seems to be stalling.
Two of the top five picks in 2014 are busts, though. Sam Bennett and Michael Dal Colle were regrettable choices.
Jake has 15 goals, 27 points in 89 games over the last two seasons with an average of 12:07 of TOI per game.
This season, he has 5 goals, 7 points in 14 games with 12:49 of TOI per game and is shooting 18.5% with 27 shots on goal so far (1.93 per game). Last year, he had a shooting percentage of 7.7%.
1.93 shots per game would equate to 158 shots over 82 games. Last season, he had 130 shots, but a low shooting percentage. A 13% shooting percentage over 158 shots would be 20 goals, so as long as Jake keeps putting the puck on net, his shooting percentage can drop to 13% from his current 18.5% and he would still be looking at a 20-goal season. A higher shooting percentage would mean 20+ this year; an 18.5% shooting percentage over 158 shots is 29 goals, for example. He's on pace for 158 shots this season while receiving 12:49 per game. He is generating chances, and this season his chances look more dangerous than before; he isn't just lobbing pucks into the goaltender's chest anymore.
If Jake gains some consistency, I think he'll receive more ice time and be in a great position to break out this year. More ice time means more shots on goal. His shooting technique looks better so far, and his forechecking is one of his strongest attributes. He doesn't play on the first powerplay unit either.
At his current rate of shots per minute, an increase to 15 minutes per game would bring his estimated number of shots this season up to 185. A 13% shooting percentage over 185 shots is 24 goals. A 15% shooting percentage would equate to 27 goals. A 17% shooting percentage would equate to 31 goals.
Effectively, if he continues to put shots on goal at his current rate but plays second-line minutes and converts at a decent rate (13-15%), he can hit 25 to 30 goals.
5 goals over 14 games prorates to 29 goals over 82. A 20 to 25 goal pace is actually quite sustainable as long as Jake's shooting percentage doesn't plummet. He's doing a lot with his ice time, and he isn't getting much ice time.
Jake just turned 22, and this year seems likely to be his breakout season.