I've always liked Pronman, as stated he goes out to see prospects live and substantiates his positions with detailed observations and reasoning. I suppose it depends on whether one trusts his prospect evaluation acumen.
Also, it just may be fact that NYI does not have many high end prospects; which they do not.
I get you.
I have nothing against Pronman himself. Quite the contrary. And such lists really are hard to put together.
I just think that we can take these things with a grain of salt, because there are a lot of players ahead of Dobson (ranked 74th) on that list who haven't even begun to show why they're so highly thought of in even the AHL, much less the NHL.
And since Pronman is naming such players to this list, then he's clearly taking the long-term impact of those guys into account more than just the here and now.
If that's the case, I believe anyone in the know who has any inkling of what Dobson has for a tool set can look at that list and pick a good handful of names of guys who do not look to have the kind of impactful future in store that Dobson has, yet are ranked ahead of him.
As for our prospect system, I'm sure that all the respective outlets will have ours ranked near the bottom of the league. Just not enough sexy names in our organization and too many of the former "blue chippers" (namely Wahlstrom and Bellows) have seen their sexiness status take hits in recent years.