Safarite
Registered User
- Jan 19, 2016
- 260
- 29
It's a common argument for fans (and people on this board) to say that teams need both an elite #1 Centerman and Defensemen in order to win The Cup. In fact, you'd have to go back all the way to the 05-06 Hurricanes to find a team that did not have both.
However, of the four remaining teams in this playoffs, I'd argue that Nashville is the only team that inarguably has both such players on their team.
Pittsburgh of course has the two headed monster, but no Letang this year.
Anaheim has Getzlaf, but I think an argument can be made that Lindholm (or whoever Anaheim fans consider their best defensemen these playoffs) is not an elite #1 D, or at least not on par with the likes of Doughty, Keith, Lidstrom, Chara, etc.
Ottawa of course has the best defensemen in the world, but I would hardly call Turris an elite #1C.
This isn't a knock on these teams, or their players. I find what they have all accomplished this playoffs admirable and I'd be happy to see any of them win to be honest. My question is simply will the general rule of thumb of needing a #1C and #1D to win a cup be broken this season? And regardless, is there a possibility of this happening either next season or in the near future? Discuss.
Bonus question: Who do you think more valuable, a #1C or #1 D?
However, of the four remaining teams in this playoffs, I'd argue that Nashville is the only team that inarguably has both such players on their team.
Pittsburgh of course has the two headed monster, but no Letang this year.
Anaheim has Getzlaf, but I think an argument can be made that Lindholm (or whoever Anaheim fans consider their best defensemen these playoffs) is not an elite #1 D, or at least not on par with the likes of Doughty, Keith, Lidstrom, Chara, etc.
Ottawa of course has the best defensemen in the world, but I would hardly call Turris an elite #1C.
This isn't a knock on these teams, or their players. I find what they have all accomplished this playoffs admirable and I'd be happy to see any of them win to be honest. My question is simply will the general rule of thumb of needing a #1C and #1D to win a cup be broken this season? And regardless, is there a possibility of this happening either next season or in the near future? Discuss.
Bonus question: Who do you think more valuable, a #1C or #1 D?
Last edited: