Is it time to re-sign Nelson?

[majormet]

I have killed this guy over the past few years and probably because he had so much potential and never really showed it, but he has been doing a very good Ryan Kesler imitation in the first 18 games of the year and we are 2 weeks into November and it seems like he is for real now.

The question is at what point do you resign him, this to me is Bailey 2.0, and in some ways his development path has been a little faster than Bailey.

What do you all think?

Click to read more...

 

[SI90]

Forget the points and goals. He’s looked like a completely different player. That being said, it’s way to esrlybto make that decision. Also, I don’t think right now he’s a reasonable long term answer as the #2 Center. Very pleased with his play thus far though and have to give credit when it’s due.

 

[djavan]

If they can get another center/wing via trade that has size and is defensively responsible. Cizikas is already “nicked up” and though I love what Filppula provides I don’t think it’ll remain over 82 games. Yes, he’s playing well

 

[BelovedIsles]

I wouldn’t, small sample in a contract year. He’s getting good coaching, he’s making a commitment to both ends of the rink, he’s scoring (even in November). W all that said, he’s not a traditional center, would prefer more playmaking, there are better options out there.

 

[mm11]

personally i think he is an option for a solid top 6 winger. Learning to play center alittle bit does help his 200 foot game and gives the isles some flexibility. Tough call committing to a long term contract with Nelson. This is why Lou is getting paid now. Glad it's not me making the decision...

 

[Islesfan22]

I have killed this guy over the past few years and probably because he had so much potential and never really showed it, but he has been doing a very good Ryan Kesler imitation in the first 18 games of the year and we are 2 weeks into November and it seems like he is for real now.

The question is at what point do you resign him, this to me is Bailey 2.0, and in some ways his development path has been a little faster than Bailey.

What do you all think?

I think we need to wait and see before we decide whether to sign or not. I’m still skeptical as one it’s a contract year and two we have seen good starts from Brock in the past.

 

[MJF]

I have killed this guy over the past few years and probably because he had so much potential and never really showed it, but he has been doing a very good Ryan Kesler imitation in the first 18 games of the year and we are 2 weeks into November and it seems like he is for real now.

The question is at what point do you resign him, this to me is Bailey 2.0, and in some ways his development path has been a little faster than Bailey.

What do you all think?

After we re-sign Lee. He should be first with an offer. Let Nelson wait until January while he keeps producing.

Could it be that Trotz is the right coach to finally reach Brock Nelson?

 

[Poulin 0n My St1ck]

Trade him in a package for a defenseman. He’ll turn back into a pumpkin before you know it.

 

[Seph]

Depends on what he's willing to sign for right now. I wouldn't sign him to a huge contract right now, but that's probably what he's looking for.

 

[seafoam]

Not yet.

 

[lazycop]

Based on his battle-level and uninspired play in the past, to me he's got 'Gets new contract and immediately coasts' written all over him.

I'd deal him in a heartbeat if the right deal came along.

 

[majormet]

After we re-sign Lee. He should be first with an offer. Let Nelson wait until January while he keeps producing.

Could it be that Trotz is the right coach to finally reach Brock Nelson?

I think any good coach could have reached Nelson, we just never had a good coach, that is why our players don't develop that fast, poor Bailey was coached by a cheesy rap video star, the king of Bedrock and then the shorter sidekick of the king of Bedrock

Team should offer Lee, then Nelson, then Filp.... I think Eberle can be let go of

 

[CREW99AW]

personally i think he is an option for a solid top 6 winger. Learning to play center alittle bit does help his 200 foot game and gives the isles some flexibility. Tough call committing to a long term contract with Nelson. This is why Lou is getting paid now. Glad it's not me making the decision...

Even with Nelson's strong start, I am leery about commiting big bucks to such an inconsistent player, motivated by a contract yr.
Is the biggest difference in his game Trotz's influence or pushing for the biggest contract of his career?
Is this the Nelson we will see in future seasons or will he slide back into complacency after getting his contract?

Brock has said he hopes to stay. Like you, I am glad the decision falls on Lou.

 

[Brunomics]

I think if I can lock him up for 5 years 5.5-6 million yes.

If He ends up going for 30+ goals and 65 points he just might get over 7 million in today's market which would be crazy.

 

[Brunomics]

Even with Nelson's strong start, I am leery about commiting big bucks to such an inconsistent player, motivated by a contract yr.
Is the biggest difference in his game Trotz's influence or pushing for the biggest contract of his career?
Is this the Nelson we will see in future seasons or will he slide back into complacency after getting his contract?

Brock has said he hopes to stay. Like you, I am glad the decision falls on Lou.

I want to say it's Trotz because he's effective in all three zones. If he was just putting up points I would say it's all about the contract.

Also remember Weight and Capuano really were garbage coaches. This is his first real NHL caliber coach.

 

[PK Cronin]

I don't trust that Nelson is able to play the third center spot and be productive, I also don't trust that he'll continue to produce the way he is and would prefer and upgrade at the second center position. Not interested in re-signing him until much closer to the deadline and I'd prefer to trade him as it stands right now.

Pet peeve: It's re-sign, not resign.

 

[MJF]

I think any good coach could have reached Nelson, we just never had a good coach, that is why our players don't develop that fast, poor Bailey was coached by a cheesy rap video star, the king of Bedrock and then the shorter sidekick of the king of Bedrock

Barney Rubble?

 

[Skip To My Lou]

You don't know if this the "Trotz-effect" or this is just him playing for a new contract. I remember Drew Stafford was notorious for playing lights out at the end of his contract and then milking it out once he got it. Just don't want him to lolly-gag around if we do re-sign him. A lot of risk comes along with it.

 

[Kevin27NYI]

Yes.

 

[BTrotts19]

Not sure I can trust that this is the "new & improved" Nelson. It would be great to give him an incentive-laden contract to almost force him to be committed. I would offer him $4.5M/6 yr contract and if he doesn't want something under $5M/AAV, start working the trade routes to package him and get someone more reliable and more a prototypical 2C or a 4D.

 

[Lame Lambert]

No it is definitely not the time to sign Nelson. Even if he keeps this play up through the whole year I’m not sure if it’s the right move to sign him.

 

[buud]

re-sign

[ree-sahyn]
Word Origin
See more synonyms for re-sign on Thesaurus.com
verb (used with or without object)

1. to sign again.
2. to renew or extend a contract.

re·sign

(rĭ-zīn′)
v. re·signed, re·sign·ing, re·signs
v.tr.
1. To submit (oneself) passively; accept as inevitable: I resigned myself to a long wait in line.
2. To give up (a position, for example), especially by formal notification.
3. To relinquish (a privilege, right, or claim). See Synonyms at relinquish.

 

[MJF]

No it is definitely not the time to sign Nelson. Even if he keeps this play up through the whole year I’m not sure if it’s the right move to sign him.

Then the right move is to trade him when he’s scoring and has a pulse.

 

[doublechili]

Re-sign him and hope the hypnotist doesn't die.

 

[Lame Lambert]

Then the right move is to trade him when he’s scoring and has a pulse.

Agreed. Trade him now.