Alkurtz and Revel- I agree with your observations and do not think they are reflective of the odd game.
Ryan Graves is a very good hockey player. He is developed into an offensive 2-way D in the Q, lets not be fooled by were he was picked and slot him in as a stay-at-home type with a heavy shot. He won't be overly fancy, but you don't have to be that. He isn't overly punishing on a shift-by-shift basis, and he of course don't skate like Doughty or Brodin and the likes, but he is very solid overall. We got a steal in him. Then of course skating, puck management, gap-control and those things will be a challenge of some sort for him in the NHL.
If you take the established job specification for a NHL D 5-10 years ago maybe, Graves is a 8 on a 10 scale. If you take the established job specification for a NHL D last summer, he is maybe a 5.5 on a 10 scale. That is probably why he fell. But, this is something we have seen before. It is so valuable to skate well in the league right now, and to be able to turn the game fast that that is what everyone is looking for now. The next Gotisbherre. But, its when "everyone" is looking for size you can steal guys like Zetterberg and Datsyuk in 7th or 5th rounds. When we drafted Graves his mobility didn't stand out and his offensive game was still latent, like for many kids you draft potential, but since he wasn't a standout in terms of mobility he fell much more than he should have had.
I like Brady Skjei and think he will become a good player in this league. But I think there is a risk with expecting him to be something he is not. He is kind of a Kreider on defense. Don't expect him to be Brassard if you get what I mean.
However, when I saw Skjei in the WJCs his vision and puck moving ability was not as good at all as it is right now. It does seem like he himself as well as the coaching staff really has figured out what the game is about and what Skjei needs to improve. I saw a few of Skjei's first games in the AHL last season and he 100% focused on working on the right things. Making those plays with the puck and using his skating to his strength. I do not think he will become John Moore II. But vision and hockey sense is an ability like any other, we don't expect Tambo to learn to skate like Brassard just because he has good hands and we can't count on Skjei picking up the vision and hockey sense of a true PMD just because he skates really well. But hopefully Skjei can build a lot on it. I do think playing in HFD will be good for him, but maybe I would like to see him play for a bit better team?? You always get to play more with the puck if you play for a better team and PMDs playing for bad teams are really pressured hard and often heads off in the wrong direction.
Mat Bodie, I wouldn't count him out as a NHL prospect. I wouldn't bet on it, but I remember like it was yesterday when I traveled to the Arena Delfinen in Sweden and saw this 23 y/o midget from US College Hockey hit the ice for Brynäs with a way too big sweater. We joked that you couldn't tell the difference between him and the kids escorting the players to the ice. He was cut loose by his SHL because he just was way to weak for the SHL and played the coming 3 years in Finland. That D retired with over 500 pts in 800 NHL games and must have won 3-4 Stanley Cups and got 100 pts in 165 PO games.
Bodie won't become Rafalski II, but I wouldn't rule out that he will make the NHL one day.