This was not an offer per se, I simply threw a base offer out there of some names and picks and asked if it would be enough and go from there.
Also, I get you want the most for your player, but how many times have teams gotten in real life trades what HF perceived as good value?
Remember the Kane or Skinner trades? 95% of HF boards thought these trades were crap, yet they still happened.
What HF perceives as a "horrible trade" is a moot point.
If you were to counter with what I believe is a lobsided trade I would simply say that I can't do that and doit the Habs do it as well and that's that.
I wouldn't comment that you are on crack and you should stop following hockey and start following ping pong.
Anyways, I believe an NHL ready player, one or two prospects and a couple picks is good return.
It may be scrap to the Ducks, but it may also be good enough and they pull the trigger if indeed they want to really shake things up and change the culture in the team.