Proposal: Habs - Ducks

[Coming Home]

to MTL:
Cam Fowler + 2nd

To ANA:
Plekanec
Emelin
Desharnais/Beaulieu.

Habs would get the top 2 D they require as well as clearing cap space for possible signing of Shipachev.
Ducks get established 2C plus top 4D plus 3C/young established D.

The cap numbers work well for both teams.

Click to read more...

 

[Treb]

Ducks have an internal cap.

Habs need one of DD/Plek for 2nd C.

 

[WhatTheDuck]

to MTL:
Cam Fowler + 2nd

To ANA:
Plekanec
Emelin
Desharnais/Beaulieu.

Habs would get the top 2 D they require as well as clearing cap space for possible signing of Shipachev.
Ducks get established 2C plus top 4D plus 3C/young established D.

The cap numbers work well for both teams.

When did we start calling the Habs "both teams" ? This is not what Anaheim is looking for at all, and that's putting it as politely as possible.

 

[Coming Home]

Ducks have an internal cap.

Habs need one of DD/Plek for 2nd C.

Shipachev would be the 2C

 

[gilfaizon]

Galch or GTFO

 

[BigSquid]

I would imagine Kesler is the 2C over Pleks. Lots of salary going back at the ducks. Doubt this has much legs.

 

[crosscheck2]

Why Anaheim wants Emelin?

 

[crosscheck2]

One of the worst proposals that I have ever seen.

 

[Coming Home]

Why Anaheim wants Emelin?

Currently Ducks have 6 D signed plus RFA Lindholm. Emelin would be the 7th Dman

 

[CanadienShark]

Beaulieu >>> Desharnais.

The deal with DD is a steal for the Habs. The deal with Beaulieu is closer.

 

[WhatTheDuck]

Beaulieu >>> Desharnais.

The deal with DD is a steal for the Habs. The deal with Beaulieu is closer.

Neither of them make a shred of sense for the Ducks.

 

[Sweoilers]

And this helps Ducks to sign Lindholm how exactly? Also internal cap would get totally destroyed by this.

 

[crosscheck2]

Currently Ducks have 6 D signed plus RFA Lindholm. Emelin would be the 7th Dman

They just signed Holzer and they have Theodore / Montour. Once again: Why do they want Emelin?

 

[Spazkat]

to MTL:
Cam Fowler + 2nd

To ANA:
Plekanec
Emelin
Desharnais/Beaulieu.

Habs would get the top 2 D they require as well as clearing cap space for possible signing of Shipachev.
Ducks get established 2C plus top 4D plus 3C/young established D.

The cap numbers work well for both teams.

You think the cap works for both teams when Habs take on 4M and dump >12 on the Ducks?

 

[Sojourn]

Currently Ducks have 6 D signed plus RFA Lindholm. Emelin would be the 7th Dman

...a $4 million 7th defenseman. Think about that for a second.

Does that really make sense?

 

[Day of the Duck]

How does the cap work well for both teams?

 

[CanadienShark]

Neither of them make a shred of sense for the Ducks.

I agree.

 

[BatVader]

Aaaannnnnd...... Flush

 

[Tiger Svoboda]

to MTL:
Cam Fowler + 2nd

To ANA:
Plekanec
Emelin
Desharnais/Beaulieu.

Habs would get the top 2 D they require as well as clearing cap space for possible signing of Shipachev.
Ducks get established 2C plus top 4D plus 3C/young established D.

The cap numbers work well for both teams.

Habs cannot trade Plekanec. He plays all the hard minutes for them. And the Ducks don't needs him since they have Kesler in the same role. Fowler to MTL make sense but you have to look at something else for this to work.

 

[Coming Home]

...a $4 million 7th defenseman. Think about that for a second.

Does that really make sense?

He would be one of the 7 D on the roster, not the 7th on the depth chart.

 

[Sojourn]

Habs cannot trade Plekanec. He plays all the hard minutes for them. And the Ducks don't needs him since they have Kesler in the same role. Fowler to MTL make sense but you have to look at something else for this to work.

Fowler to Montreal is the only direction it makes sense. The assets that Anaheim would want from Montreal are the ones you wouldn't want to move.

 

[Sojourn]

He would be one of the 7 D on the roster, not the 7th on the depth chart.

Even better. So we have one of Stoner, Bieksa, Despres, or Emelin as our 7th defenseman. Either way, it doesn't work. Anaheim wants to move at least one of those first three defensemen. They don't want to add another overpaid depth player.

You're sending far too much salary Anaheim's way, and the big piece (Plekanec) is redundant. The Ducks don't need an established 2C. They have Ryan Kesler. Not that Plekanec wouldn't be a nice addition, but it's still an unnecessary piece.

You didn't consider Anaheim's needs at all in this deal. Like, at all. You're giving us a defenseman we don't need, and a center we don't need(but who would be a nice luxury).

 

[McDonald19]

Fowler will be moved for young forward talent.

This is a horrible proposal for Anaheim.

 

[alexhabs26]

Fowler would be a nice addition to the deffence in Montreal and he could play with Weber, but I don't think that Anaheim want the salary of Emelin, Plekanec and Desharnais.
Also Anaheim alredy have a 2c in Kesler.
If Montreal trade Plekanec, Montreal will have a big hole in the second line. To trade Plekanec, habs should sign Shipachev or add a top 6 center first.

 

[Moose Head]

Jesus Murphy. A trade that works for no one.