Value of: Gaudreau

[Neutrinos]

This one is close


Interesting. I would definitely think about this pretty hard. Is there anything reasonable that could be added to also score nylander? Respectfully I feel like johnny and mony are worth a bit more than matthews alone when contracts are considered.

That's just it though, when you consider contracts, Gaudreau has only 2 more years left on his deal before hitting UFA

Monahan has 3, Matthews has 4

 

[Neutrinos]

That is the thing though, flames could easily look silly if Johnny goes to Buffalo and posts seasons with 100+ points.

Even if Reinhart and Middlestat progress we could still easily lose the trade.

Calgary could just say they didn't think Gaudreau was likely to re-sign, or they didn't want to pay his asking price of 10+ million

 

[Flameshomer]

That's just it though, when you consider contracts, Gaudreau has only 2 more years left on his deal before hitting UFA

Monahan has 3, Matthews has 4

I actually wasnt thinking of length so that's fair. Hit wise though Monahan and gaudreau only come out to 13.5 ish together vs 10.5 alone for Matthews

Edit: y'know, I changed my mind. The flames should easily accept mony-Johnny for matthews.

 

[QcFlames12]

Calgary could just say they didn't think Gaudreau was likely to re-sign

Yeah but he is still multiple years from UFA status.

It's a gamble, and I like Reinhart, especially when considering his all around game.

Just seems iffy, which usually is a good indication that this trade is close in value.

 

[Neutrinos]

I actually wasnt thinking of length so that's fair. Hit wise though Monahan and gaudreau only come out to 13.5 ish together vs 10.5 alone for Matthews

Edit: y'know, I changed my mind. The flames should easily accept mony-Johnny for matthews.

Matthews makes 11.63 million

 

[is the answer jesus]

As a Sabres fan I usually despise any deal that involves Reinhart, but landing Gaudreau would be incredible. Solid proposal.

 

[Muffin]

I think Tkachuk is ready to take over as the franchise player over Gaudreau. He's the kind of player you win in the playoffs with not Gaudreau.

 

[CraigsList]

Im asking for a King’s ransom.

Although Gaudreau has been pretty bad this year, he’s still put up 18 points in 22 games.

Don’t think anything happens during the season, but don’t be surprised if a big trade is made during the off-season.

 

[Remember2004]

Doesn't Johnny want to end up with the Flyers or something? What could Flyers offer for him? Patrick+?

 

[Sam Pollock]

Doesn't Johnny want to end up with the Flyers or something? What could Flyers offer for him? Patrick+?

Are you using Nolan Patrick as your starting point for Johnny Gaudreau ? The same Patrick that has migraine issues and never had more than 31 points in a season? Start with Couturier and start adding from there. Imagine Giroux and Gaudreau together on the same line and you'll understand why it starts with Couturier.

 

[elitepete]

Miller+Gaudette?

 

[Devonator]

Are you using Nolan Patrick as your starting point for Johnny Gaudreau ? The same Patrick that has migraine issues and never had more than 31 points in a season? Start with Couturier and start adding from there. Imagine Giroux and Gaudreau together on the same line and you'll understand why it starts with Couturier.

WE wouldn't be adding anything for Gaudreau if we are offering Couturier....I am sure most would agree that is a fair trade ....personally I want nothing to do with Johnny Midget...he is useless when the going gets tough...he is great in the regular season but he is just to tiny for the rough stuff in the playoffs...I just hope my Flyers do not make a stupid move in trying to acquire this little gaffer!

 

[QcFlames12]

WE wouldn't be adding anything for Gaudreau if we are offering Couturier....I am sure most would agree that is a fair trade ....personally I want nothing to do with Johnny Midget...he is useless when the going gets tough...he is great in the regular season but he is just to tiny for the rough stuff in the playoffs...I just hope my Flyers do not make a stupid move in trying to acquire this little gaffer!

It's pretty fair, seeing position and defensive play.

I would consider it, but would prefer the Buffalo proposal.

 

[andora]

That is the thing though, flames could easily look silly if Johnny goes to Buffalo and posts seasons with 100+ points.

Even if Reinhart and Middlestat progress we could still easily lose the trade.

which team wins more games in that scenario? gaudreau can score 200 points but if calgary gets a better team out of it can you say they lost a trade? if the player isn't scoring 100+ points in calgary maybe he isn't going to?

 

[Limeyjim]

I'd be elated to see the Flyers acquire Johnny Hockey. If it took sending Voracek + Patrick etc. I'm all for it.

 

[QcFlames12]

which team wins more games in that scenario? gaudreau can score 200 points but if calgary gets a better team out of it can you say they lost a trade? if the player isn't scoring 100+ points in calgary maybe he isn't going to?

I do think there is a clear gap between Monny and Eichel.

Sure we are getting deeper and taking a gamble that Middlestat progresses but are losing a star.

Johnny is a game changer and when giving up a game changer you have to assure that you are receiving pieces that are worth it.

If Reinhart comes to Calgary and only puts up 45 points a year and Middlestat tops out as a third line 30 point forward that would be horrible, however if Reinhart maintains his pace and Middlestat becomes a great 2nd line center we make out far better.

Alot of this trade would rely on Middlestat taking a huge step in his game.

I think it's easy to imagine Gaudreau putting up at least 90 with one of the best centers in the league.

 

[Tripod]

Are you using Nolan Patrick as your starting point for Johnny Gaudreau ? The same Patrick that has migraine issues and never had more than 31 points in a season? Start with Couturier and start adding from there. Imagine Giroux and Gaudreau together on the same line and you'll understand why it starts with Couturier.

Flyers would not trade Couts 1-1 for DG.

He is too important in BOTH ends of the ice.

Flyers don't need a LW...that's where Giroux should be playing and well as having Lindblom and JVR.

 

[AintLifeGrand]

To CGY: Tolvanen, Kyle Turris, 1st Round 2020, Calle Jarnkrok
T0 Nash: Johnny Hockey

 

[madmike77]

Lmao thats terrible for Calgary.. youre a Flames fan? Pls watch more hockey games.

You haven't seen Gaudreau since last year's All Star break. He's not the same player he was early last year.

 

[Blaine8797]

Something is foul in our locker room. What are your best offers?

What would you be looking for from philly, as he is very close to the city

 

[Blaine8797]

Are you using Nolan Patrick as your starting point for Johnny Gaudreau ? The same Patrick that has migraine issues and never had more than 31 points in a season? Start with Couturier and start adding from there. Imagine Giroux and Gaudreau together on the same line and you'll understand why it starts with Couturier.

You will never get coots I promise, realistically voracek a blue chip prospect and maybe a first would do it

 

[CraigsList]

To CGY: Tolvanen, Kyle Turris, 1st Round 2020, Calle Jarnkrok
T0 Nash: Johnny Hockey

Not a bad offer, but the Flames will do all they can to not trade quality for quantity.

 

[InfinityIggy]

Trading Gaudreau in season is what we call a phenomenally bad idea.

 

[jw2]

Something is foul in our locker room. What are your best offers?

Backes, Halak + 2nd

 

[Habs Halifax]

Matthews makes 11.63 million

This might change his mind again?

Flames should chill. Expectations heading into this season are higher than they were last year and this put pressure on where they should be as a hockey team this year.

Flames 9th best defensive team last year and so far this year, they are 26th. This is why you are not meeting expectations