Foppa2118
Registered User
- Oct 3, 2003
- 52,301
- 31,422
I'm sorry but if Cale is fighting it, then what exactly are Cole, Zadorov and Graves doing out there? Because they were a million times worse out there than Makar last night. Makar was easily it 3rd best dman last night.
In fact I liked his overall defensive game tonight. Had a hiccup or two but overall he was making the simple plays to get the puck out of harms way. The only goal against he was on the ice for was that BS goal by Tarasenko that should never have gone in from a miserable angle. That one was on Grubauer.
The other three I mentioned earlier were a trainwreck last night.
I think Cale was better defensively last night, though there was a couple moments he got lucky. He's struggled in that area a lot this year, especially on dump ins, but that wasn't his issue last night.
His decision making with the puck is where he was still struggling. Overhandling the puck, and telegraphing his outlet passes. He's having trouble with the speed of NHL forecheckers, and it's leading to mistakes. He's also overthinking his options, and by the time he picks one, one or two forecheckers are putting a lot of pressure on him.
I've always supported Makar while others questioned his abilities, so don't lump me in with some of the hot takes about him. I only base my takes on what I see on the ice, and critique or praise where I think it's fair to do so, without regard for who it is. Good or bad.
Makar is having some rookie moments so far this year though, despite the points. I'm not overly concerned about it. I think he'll get it figured out, and get better as the season goes on, but he does have things he needs to work on.