That’s an interesting argument. I’ve been working on the assumption that it’s probably this year or bust for the Bruins, but you may have something there. This team is understandably tired, and it’s an open question whether they will be able to sufficiently prepare and lift themselves physically and mentally for another deep playoff run. Chances are they won’t be able to and it would be harsh to criticize them if it does pan out that way. The NHL postseason is the most brutal in sport, and it’s with good reason that the Penguins and Red Wings are the only teams in the salary cap era to make back-to-back SCFs, which is all the more impressive for Pittsburgh in their having done it twice.
Perhaps Boston will be fresher and more likely to sustain a good run next season. But there are clear risks in going down that path. Even if Chara were to re-sign, he’s at an age and point in his career where his athletic ability could simply fall off a cliff at any time. And that will be another year older for Bergy, Krejci and even the likes of Marchand and Rask, increasing their chances of injury or simple burn out and loss of form. On the flip side it’s another year of experience for Gryz, Clifton, Studnicka, Kuhlman, McAvoy etc. and as you say a chance to really re-think the roster and add some much needed steel, strength and finish rather than just tinkering before the upcoming deadline.
I guess we’ll just have to see what Sweeney does, and whether he goes all in for this year or is content for now just to add a little value, hope for the best, and properly re-evaluate in the offseason with an eye to next year being the big push.