Take a look at Spezza's 2nd goal against Edmonton from a few days ago. Starting at 47 sec's
http://video.nhl.com/videocenter/console?id=846422
Yakupov missed a break & then when Dallas got the puck he worked his ass off to get back. Didn't really make the right choices in his own end, but the effort was there.
By contrast, McDavid coasted from the turnover until the goal. If you can read a dangerous offensive chance forming, then you should be able to read it when it's forming against your team. Yesterdays game with McDavid involved a lot of "watching" in his own end & a -3 outcome.
Many Oiler fans seem to think he has a strong defensive game, but at the NHL level he hasn't shown it.
Imagine McDavid if he was drafted by Toronto & had 1 G in 4 games & a well earned -5 to boot. The media would be insane.
3 Goals in 4 games by 4 first overall picks, if you draft them for their offence but they can't produce, what do you have? I think Edmonton is still broke & if they don't start coaching their "stars" to be real NHL 200' players they will end up with a mish mash of super shinny hockey players.