Hunter Shepard 18/22 .818 SV% 4GA 6-4 win
Darcy Kuemper 13/17 .765 SV% 4GA 1-4 loss
The biggest difference between the two goalies, Shepard was playing in his first ever NHL game and he didn't give up any short-side or leaky goals. He didn't cheat his angles, he plays the percentages and he plays patient. You could even argue that the Devils are a faster skating team than the Leafs. What I liked about Shepard, he was impressively even keel the whole game and he battled hard. Not sure you could say the same for Kuemper in his start against the Leafs.
Not sure what you think, but I think Shepard should either get the next start as well against the Wild or if you go back to Kuemper, then Shepard should start against the Sharks.