Yes, they're impactful immediately.
MacKinnon drafted, playoffs same year.
McDavid drafted, playoffs the next year.
Matthews drafted, playoffs same year.
How about teams more around our level?
J. Hughes drafted, playoffs in 4th year.
M. Barzal drafted, playoffs in 4th year.
Tim Stutzle drafted, on pace to miss playoffs yet again in 4th year.
We can keep going. I'm describing players and the success they had in their early 20s or even teens.
Nobody is asking for the Stanley Cup today but to win a Stanley Cup you need to start making the playoffs and this team has not shown anything that would make you believe they can make the playoffs.
I mean you’re using some of the very best 1oa picks of their generations as your examples though. Most young players don’t make a huge impact immediately. stammer and Hedman are examples of star 1OAs that needed time to have an impact on team success.
As the previous lists shows, most of those cup champ teams had star players in their mid to late 20’s to support/lead the young stars. Our mid to late players are good, but not star calibre at this point, and not the main leaders of the team save for Chabby.
My point wasn’t that I don’t wish we were better, or could be with different GM and or coaching staff, my point was that even if their points prime may statistically be in the lower 20’s many of these young stars need to be older to make a bigger winning impact.
We don’t have late 20’s super star players to lead the way here unfortunately. I suspect that when Sandy, Stu, and Brady are in their mid to late late 20’s they will be much more impactful in team success.
We need more, and better, vet support for the young core in my opinion. G is great, Tank has played pretty well, but we need more guys who know how to win. And we need a new coach. Like many I don’t like the lack of motor and lack of physicality of the team in general this year outside of the usual suspects, and Joseph.
I guess my point is that I don’t see our young core being in their prime right now. Only Brady is starting to enter a phase where he is trying to be more impactful on team success. Hard to perhaps convey what I’m saying, but I don’t disagree with your post.