I don't think that's the point some of us are trying to make - at least I know it's not mine.
If the team is relying on Brodie to play 20 ES minutes a night, I think that's a clear indication the organization, or at least one of the important people in it think he's our #1 guy. Which he isn't, and that's not just a what have you done for me lately, it seems widely agreed that he's not at the level, and hasn't been for more than just a little stretch.
If they aren't willing to strip some of that time away from Brodie, and give it to Giordano (our true #1) or spread the minutes out amongst the other pairs, then they need to get someone who can be. That's the point, because it's abundantly clear that T.J can't handle it. That doesn't mean getting someone who is a Brodie comparable, that means an upgrade.
I don't think that has to be done, though. Giordano is still playing at an elite level where he can be that guy.
If it's agreed Brodie has he playing at a #3/#4 level, play him as a #3/#4. Is that not a logical argument?