Leo this ain’t personal but..
Sellan is 5’9. He offers nothing for me but an undersized mid level OA.
so I’ll say it again myself, if Erie thinks they can go into this year with an undersized, young team, including 7 forwards under 5’10 then I hope they have another sub par season. Further If Chris Hartsburg continues to obsess over this OA line like it’s elite talent, I swear to god I’m going to reach my breaking point. Let’s trade Swankler for peanuts and watch him pot 25g and 60+ points while Sproule finds success somewhere else. Meanwhile let’s reunite the amazing, top tier line of
Hoff/Sellan/Danny line (HSD) and get sub PPG from the trio.
I want Hoffmann and DAmato for their size. Not to unite them on some “forceful” 3rd line that Erie continues to believe they have. Emphasis on 3rd line.
I’ll play the game that we never know what these players will produce or be this year after 1.5 off but I know what I’m getting in Sellan and it ain’t size. At least give me Sproule who has more offensive upside.
The worst part too if we see that HSD line is that YOU KNOW, you just KNOW Hartsburg will keep them as a line. Acting like they DeBrincat-McDavid-Elie and can’t be separated
So what we will see? something like this below? Something that doesn’t spread the size, doesn’t spread the “experience” and doesn’t shelter their younger players
Sellan - Hoffmann - DAmato
Cohen - Lockhart - Saganiuk
Bressette - Terrance - Sedore
Ross - Lowe - Artichuk
Yipppie!!! Sign me up for that!!!
Hope I’m wrong and they are good no matter what but I don’t trust Hartsburg at all
Nothing personal taken, I'm not gonna be dishing anything personal
The simple matter of OA selection comes with this.
Austen Swankler is a known locker room cancer, from what I've talked and heard about is that we're likely not even going to dish him because of the awful reputation he has because we can't get a team to take him. On top of that, at multiple points I've heard he's clashed with other teammates, fought with other teammates, disrespected staff, billets, volunteers, etc. Keep in mind if you're an organization such as Erie, these are just the things I myself have heard, not everything that's actually happened. I've spoken with probably 1/3-1/2 of the team and a decent amount of them have had something unusual to say about the guy. I even heard that Lockhart and him absolutely hate each other. So there's a hot chance you could say they won't even want to be on a line together.
Even before he came to Erie, most people knew about his attitude issues and his drama, hence why he even switched leagues in the first place.
Even if you take all of what I just wrote above, which is purely from things I've heard and talked about with people, you still have Austen Swankler, the producing OFFENSIVE forward. When you look at Erie, we're statistically the shortest team in the OHL I'm pretty sure. We're also one of the only teams that have a relatively good defensive structure and play. We were one of the lowest-scoring teams in the league yet we put up decent defensive zone numbers in advanced statistics. If you take out the fact that the majority of Swanklers points came from Yetman, Golod, Fowler, or Drysdale, you realistically can replace him with most players on this team. How difficult is it to get points when you have a 40 goal scorer, 70+ point producer, a solid playmaker, and the arguably top defenceman in the league helping you. Regardless, he still has to score these goals and make those passes, he's a talented player and he has offensive upside. However, when you look at his time distribution on the ice and his most efficient areas of play, they're primarily offensive and primarily Power Play. Swankler was on the powerplay the majority of the year, on a powerplay that had an abysmal season all things considered. Most goals from our powerplay came from Yetman or Golod. To say that Swankler can put up 60+ points in a season isn't unrealistic, it can happen, but to keep an offensive, locker room cancer in your room is a death sentence, especially when you want your OA group to be leaders. The amount of influence your OA group has on a younger core, ESPECIALLY on a team that missed a whole season and will have about half the team being rookies, is immense.
When you look at a guy like D'amato, you have a 6'2 frame, speed, improving scoring ability, offensive-leaning 2 way player. He works his bag off no matter the scenario, he has a great motor, he's had to work for everything considering he broke his Femur in his minor midget year and came in as a midget draft pick. He is without a doubt someone we would keep. I don't hear much about him from other people other than the usual, he's a well rounded kid with a good head on his shoulders, he has the drive necessary to push him into becoming a standout OA player. The issue with him comes with the possibility that he doesn't produce due to injury and other setbacks mentally, his strength is something I'd be worried about considering he's on the lighter side of 6'2. Other than that he's a safe pick as an OA
One of the things I noticed about him regarding his playing time, he played powerplay 3 times this entire year.
And guess who with, and how many times they scored?
Hoffmann-Sellan-D'amato
2/3
If I'm not wrong it was against Saginaw both times before the season ended. The only reason I remember is that my wife said they looked like waterbugs on cocaine when they wanted the puck back.
I understand your argument against Sellan though, he's more skilled from a stickhandling point of view than either Hoffmann or D'amato or Swankler or Sproule. He just doesn't have 3 key things. 1. Size 2. Speed 2. Physicality. All three things are huge for players who want to excel considering today's game and how it's changed from 10 years ago. Sellan is a 2 way forward with a good mind for offensive structure and playmaking, simple matter of fact is that if he can't keep up with anyone on his team then he'll be a liability. However, he's arguably one of the most poised players on the team, he has the ability to finish offensive plays with his mind quicker than anyone I've seen on the returning group. He had a good amount of points throughout the showcase and has shown he can finish at a good efficiency against high-caliber players, now we have to see if that can translate to the season.
Hoffmann should be a lock coming back, the guy is 6'3-4 and he's an absolute freight train. Despite being an OA there's a ton of untapped potential. If he can have a resurgence of scoring ability and remain as physically strong and fast he is, he can be an absolute head turner come October. Hoffmann is bigger, stronger, arguably faster if not almost as fast as D'amato, and has all the defensive upside you can look for in a two-way power forward. He was tied for most goals in the tournament and led the tournament in Faceoff Percentage as well as defensive zone efficiency. On top of that, talk amongst scouts was that he was hospitalized during the tournament for stomach flu/food poisoning apparently and he never missed a game. Another easy upside for Hoffmann is that his reputation amongst not only fans and people around Erie but also amongst players and scouts is that of a leader and an admirable guy. The downside of Hoffmann comes from his consistency and his stickhandling. He needs to be able to add finesse to his game or else he'll crumble. He has the most effective and hardest shot I've seen in a while, and yet his skill level and offensive drive hinders him from using it. However, his size, strength, defensive ability is something that literally places him in the top 3 defensive forwards in advanced stats in the entire OHL. That is something you don't have that often, especially since the last player to possess that title and ability was Kyle Petit, and before that I don't think Erie had one.
And here's the other part where I don't disagree with you.
I don't believe that they will keep the line together the entire season.
HSD will likely be split up if it's the type of season we want it to be.
D'amato-Hoffmann-Saganiuk
Lockhart-Cohen-Sellan
Sedore-Terrance-Bressette
Lowe-Artichuk- Ross
Or
Lockhart-Hoffmann-Saganiuk
D'amato-Cohen-Bressette
Sedore-Terrance-Sellan
Lowe-Artichuk-Ross
You could realistically mix it up, OR, you could keep it the same and allow other lines to get the chemistry together, as opposed to getting chemistry with forwards who will be gone in a year.
It's a simple matter of what works better together. Because there's one thing you missed when it comes to what you said:
The Otters haven't played in 16 months, and you have a line that's still got chemistry in your OA group, that's a lucky thing in today's OHL atmosphere, most teams have 0 chemistry or barely any at all between most returning players.
On top of that, if there's one line I want to have the identity and drive to motivate my younger core team, it would be a line that performs such as HSD. Because I will say, they absolutely do not have the skill such as Debrincat-Elie-Strome, or any other known line from our previous years, but they work damn near harder than them.