Moroz
Registered User
- Aug 18, 2018
- 33
- 57
I agree with Ottersguy. Without question the team defense needs to improve but when on his game Murphy is solid. Problem with that is he is not always on his game and does lack some consistency. I have not seen Campbell play but from what I read would expect him to start about 25 games this season which puts Murphy at about 40 starts.
I think it would be useful to look at some of Murphy's stats for the 2018-19 season:
GAA: 3.71 (24th in the league for goalies playing 15 or more games)
Save Percentage: .880 (25th in the league for goalies playing 15 or more games)
Shots Faced per 60 minutes of play: 30.8
Shootout Wins: 5
Shootout Losses: 1
From this I think the following conclusions can reasonably be reached:
1. He did not face an inordinate amount of shots per game, on average. This does not take into account the quality of shots faced.
2. His GAA and Save Percentage is well below league average.
3. He excelled in the shoot out. This does not take into account the degree to which his teammates did or did not excel at scoring shoot out goals.
These stats are hardly complete, and I do not know if there are more refined stats available for Murphy. My overall evaluation, based on the above and my own admittedly subjective eye test, is that Murphy is a well below league average goaltender. Moreover, there is nothing in his career stats that would suggest that his performance in 2018-19 was an anomaly.
Goaltending was obviously a huge problem for the Otters last year, particularly in the back up department. With league average goaltending last year, I think they would have squeezed into the playoffs.
For 2019-20, I think they are running a significant risk if they go just with Murphy and a rookie with no OHL experience, however highly regarded that rookie may be. I was disappointed that the Otters did not address the goaltending situation in any meaningful way last year, and I am concerned that it may again prove to be an issue in 2019-20. We shall see.