Value of: Eric Staal, Jared Spurgeon, Charlie Coyle, Nino Niederreiter

[Digitalbooya]

Hasn’t really been a fun start to the season in Minnesota. What could these players return in a trade individually or as a package deal for some of these players?

Minnesota’s needs:
-fast, skilled forwards
-youngish top 6 Center
-right handed forwards
-1st round draft picks
-top prospects

Any deals out there?

Click to read more...

 

[AK87]

Nylander trade offers incoming in 3...2...1

 

[Aintboutdatlyfe]

Leafs would be in on Spurgeon, 1st would be on the table but Kapanen (And obviously Nylander) would not.

1st, Johnsson, then either another mid round pick or a non-Liljegren/Sandin prospect is probably about as high as I could see them going for Spurgeon.

Don't know if they could reach a deal without Kapanen though I might guess, who is a big no to trading for the Leafs right now. Spurgeon is really good and you gotta give to get.

 

[57special]

Steal would be a perfect TDL pickup for a Cup contender lacking C strength. Since he has a tiny, expiring contract, most teams could afford him. What he's worth depends on how he produces this year. If it's anything close to what he has done in the previous two years then it would be a nice, but not huge, haul.

 

[Bronson]

Josh Ho-Sang for Eric Staal.

 

[mpp9]

Can Nino play LW and RW?

 

[member 157595]

Leafs would be in on Spurgeon, 1st would be on the table but Kapanen (And obviously Nylander) would not.

1st, Johnsson, then either another mid round pick or a non-Liljegren/Sandin prospect is probably about as high as I could see them going for Spurgeon.

Don't know if they could reach a deal without Kapanen though I might guess, who is a big no to trading for the Leafs right now. Spurgeon is really good.

Minnesota says f*** you if we offer anything less than Nylander for Spurgeon.

Spurgeon is a reasonable starting point for a Nylander deal if we can't get him signed.

 

[ThatGuy22]

Can Nino play LW and RW?

Yes

 

[hamzarocks]

What would be the cost of a zucker+brodin package. Nylander + what to get these two

 

[FreshSeabass]

If canes are in the playoff hunt at the deadline i would not mind having Staal back as a rental.

 

[member 157595]

If canes are in the playoff hunt at the deadline i would not mind having Staal back as a rental.

I heard Jared is the best one though

 

[Aintboutdatlyfe]

Minnesota says **** you if we offer anything less than Nylander for Spurgeon.

Spurgeon is a reasonable starting point for a Nylander deal if we can't get him signed.

lol, Nylander's not getting moved for a 29 year old who expires the year after this one.

Spurgeon is a great player but age and contract does not give him the value to pull a Nylander. I guarantee if he gets traded he doesn't fetch a player of that caliber.

So no, Spurgeon is not a reasonable starting point for Nylander. Unless you're name is Peter Chiarelli.

 

[Kevs Security]

I heard Jared is the best one though

Marc is the best in the updated version of the joke, get with the program fellas.

 

[FreshSeabass]

I heard Jared is the best one though

Been there done that!

 

[Captain Mountain]

lol, Nylander's not getting moved for a 29 year old who expires the year after this one.

Spurgeon is a great player but age and contract does not give him the value to pull a Nylander. I guarantee if he gets traded he doesn't fetch a player of that caliber.

So no, Spurgeon is not a reasonable starting point for Nylander. Unless you're name is Peter Chiarelli.

Spurgeon also isn't going to be moved for a late 1st, Johnsson and a small add.

 

[mpp9]

Yes

Pens could really use a versatile two way forward to plug on RW with Sid or shore up our LW since quality drops off heavily there after Guentzel.

You don't need or likely want Maatta. Don't have a center to give up. Sprong and a 1st for cap retention or some type of cap dump savings in the deal would get me interested.

 

[JackFr]

What would be the cost of a zucker+brodin package. Nylander + what to get these two

Why would you want to trade Nylander for a LD?

 

[member 157595]

lol, Nylander's not getting moved for a 29 year old who expires the year after this one.

Spurgeon is a great player but age and contract does not give him the value to pull a Nylander. I guarantee if he gets traded he doesn't fetch a player of that caliber.

So no, Spurgeon is not a reasonable starting point for Nylander. Unless you're name is Peter Chiarelli.

Why does Minnesota trade us Spurgeon for spare parts?

I didn't say I'd move Nylander for Spurgeon straight-up but if we cannot sign him and December is creeping around the corner I'd certainly think about Spurgeon as a trade base.

 

[Baksfamous112]

I would love Brodin on the Habs. However, I don’t see anything that Minny would like and us being ok moving.

 

[AKL]

I would love Brodin on the Habs. However, I don’t see anything that Minny would like and us being ok moving.

I bet you Poehling would be a popular ask from Wild fans

 

[hamzarocks]

Why would you want to trade Nylander for a LD?

B/c the wild would want marner for dumba and that's a deal I dont want. Spurgeon is old and has a shorter contract. Brodin is lhd but we could either shift him to the right side or let rielly play right side with him. Him rielly should compliment each other very well and would be a great top pairing. I want Zucker as well since he would be a great l/w for Matthew's and I wouldnt deal nylander for brodin without a sizable add so some of the add could be considered going towards zucker with the difference being a piece the leafs add(which would be the worst of the pieces in the deal since nylnader has quite a bit more value than brodin).

 

[member 157595]

B/c the wild would want marner for dumba and that's a deal I dont want. Spurgeon is old and has a shorter contract. Brodin is lhd but we could either shift him to the right side or let rielly play right side with him. Him rielly should compliment each other very well and would be a great top pairing. I want Zucker as well since he would be a great l/w for Matthew's and I wouldnt deal nylander for brodin without a sizable add so some of the add could be considered going towards zucker with the difference being a piece the leafs add(which would be the worst of the pieces in the deal since nylnader has quite a bit more value than brodin).

Brodin does apparently play well on the right side even though he's left-handed. You may be on to something.

 

[Baksfamous112]

I bet you Poehling would be a popular ask from Wild fans

Yes but Bergevin refused to give him in a deal for ROR, so I doubt he would bite for Brodin (neither would I)

 

[Aintboutdatlyfe]

Spurgeon also isn't going to be moved for a late 1st, Johnsson and a small add.

I literally said as much in my post, didn't you read it?

Realistically the middle ground is switching in Kapanen for Johnsson, but again, Leafs can't do that, and really probably shouldn't, again only due to age/cap/contract as Spurgeon is a great RHD.

 

[Aintboutdatlyfe]

Why does Minnesota trade us Spurgeon for spare parts?

I didn't say I'd move Nylander for Spurgeon straight-up but if we cannot sign him and December is creeping around the corner I'd certainly think about Spurgeon as a trade base.

Typically if you are rebuild which OP is insinuating you are receiving more quantity than quality. Minnesota would not receive proper value in a 1-for-1 deal with Spurgeon right now.

Kessel definitely had more value than Spurgeon and that package is as much as the Kessel deal, for example.