$3-4M would move the Oilers from 21st in spending to around 13-14. Middle of the pack.
Sure but i bet that most of those teams that are spending close to the cap have better rosters or at the very least an NHL level #2/#3 center and/or top pairing Dman.
They aren't a cap team. If they are, then "cap team" means at least half the teams ion the league, so its kind of a meaningless designation.
They are close enough to the cap and considering all the money spent, the roster should look better.
Except MacT actually seems to understand the team's needs, something Tambo never did. He hasn't been able to fill them all, but he's made more progress (on paper) on the goaltending and the defense and the forward depth than Tambo did in five years.
Identifying and executing makes a big difference.
He has now had 2 full seasons to address the center depth and has made it worse. The defense depth looks better but it's still a bunch of middling veterans and unproven prospects although i do quite like the Fayne acquisition. The group is also soft as can be.
The goaltending remains to be seen. I like the goalies but they are still relatively unproven, both of them so it's still a question mark as far as i'm concerned.
He has identified some needs but has failed to execute on some fronts, i still can't get over the fact that Arcobello and Draisaitl are the only competition for the middle center spots. It's inexplicable that MacT didn't create any competition for those spots to date.
Because Tambo's incompetence did sewer the franchise, while MacT has had just one season of work to dig the team out of the deep hole his predecessor dug.
He has had two seasons to dig the team out. Last season was arguably worse than any of the Tambo years, worst IMO and I see some slight improvement accross the board. Can they even dig out of the bottom 5 this season? It's sad that we are even discussing bottom 5 possibilities still.
Funny though: if you look at the mistakes he's made, he's shown a lot of awareness that they were mistakes and worked to correct them. He canned the assistants. He overhauled the goaltending. He got a warm body for Gagner (something most posters did not think possible). He was in on a number of the UFA C's, can't force anyone to play where they don't want to.
I don't expect perfection from a GM. I do expect them to at least have a handle on the team's needs and an ability and willingness to recognize their own mistakes and fix them. MacT seems to have those traits and that's a good thing.
He corrected the mistakes AFTER the season was sewered last season.
Is he going to wait until this season is sewered to bring in an NHL level #2/#3 center or is this another development and evaluation year?
I don't expect perfection from him but i would like to see one season, just ONE where the Oilers don't have the worst depth in the league at any position.
First it was the defense and goaltending, now it's center and even the defense and goaltending has a bunch of question marks. Outside of wing depth, is there any position that the Oilers are even middle of the pack leaguewide? At least on paper, center, defense and goaltending all rank comfortably in the bottom 10 still with center depth being the worst in the league.
I also want to add that i know this isn't an easy job. Edmonton has a long way to go to dig out of the bad reputation that it has (mainly due to management incompetence, and i'm not talking about Tambo, look much higher), but it's his job to make this franchise a winner and from what i see, they aren't much better off than they were in the Tambo years.
Maybe i'm just used to disappointment and it has made me jaded but i'm in "i'll believe it when i see it" mode. I expect the worst until I start to see better and to me, the roster doesn't really inspire much confidence. Lots of talent (unproven talent mainly) but can they finally come together as a TEAM? Who the hell knows?