Does Marchand deserve to finish top 3 in Hart voting?

[AllDay28]

All that matters is McDavid is Hart. Two is not a winner and Three nobody remembers. Plus f*** Marchand that little goof

 

[AllDay28]

Thanks for the laugh

do you have any actual evidence. Like you know, lookin at nomination history, to have this “laugh”...

btw without Toronto (and the Rangers in the states), the league folds. It’s already on par with the MLS in America.

 

[Regal]

do you have any actual evidence. Like you know, lookin at nomination history, to have this “laugh”...

btw without Toronto (and the Rangers in the states), the league folds. It’s already on par with the MLS in America.

Two laughs in one day! I'm pretty sure if someone is going to claim that the media intentionally don't vote for Toronto players, they're the one who needs to provide evidence. It's a completely unjustifiable position, but another example of this bizarre victim mentality that shows just how deluded Leafs fans are by their own media.

 

[Foppberg]

Maybe not top 3, but top 5 for sure.

McDavid

Barkov
MacKinnon
Marchand
Panarin

 

[Pyrophorus]

?

If you don't count the games the Leafs were shutout, then Matthews is amazing!!!!

Hahahahaha. That's some Leaf logic right there.

I guess B's fans don't want a player, that scores 6pts in 3games.

 

[BruinsBtn]

I guess B's fans don't want a player, that scores 6pts in 3games.

If you don't count the games where guys don't score, everyone's stats are impressive.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Gimme a break. Marchand drives his line way more than Matthews does.

Actually Marner drives that line.

 

[Golden_Jet]

do you have any actual evidence. Like you know, lookin at nomination history, to have this “laugh”...

btw without Toronto (and the Rangers in the states), the league folds. It’s already on par with the MLS in America.

Name a player worth nomination in the last 50 years.

 

[Sidney the Kidney]

do you have any actual evidence. Like you know, lookin at nomination history, to have this “laugh”...

btw without Toronto (and the Rangers in the states), the league folds. It’s already on par with the MLS in America.

When have the Leafs had a player worthy of being nominated for the Hart, but that player got snubbed because of your theory about the PHWA being worried about showing bias?

The last time Toronto had a high-end player who put up a Hart worthy season was Doug Gilmour. And would you look at that, he finished 2nd in Hart voting and won the Selke.

 

[nowhereman]

McDavid is the easy #1. But, after that, it's a crapshoot. If I had to guess, the top three in Hart voting will be McDavid (obviously), Matthews (Richard winner) and Crosby (still has the Penguins relevant with all their injuries). Kane could be there too, should the Hawks make the playoffs. I don't think Draisait will be in the mix.

 

[Over the volcano]

Yes

 

[McRpro]

Tough to say at this point. There's quite a few players that you can make an argument for at this juncture, Marchand being one of them.

 

[PatriceBergeronFan]

Deserves? Yes. Will he? No.

Outsiders don't realize yet that Marchand, McAvoy, and the goalie largely carry the Bruins each game this season.

When the Bruins are low on emotion, it's Marchand starting a scrum or fight to wake the team up, or scoring the goal. He is the MVP of the Bruins by far this season.

 

[Nathaniel Skywalker]

Mcdavid
Matthews
Crosby

 

[amnesiac]

one game without Bergeron, Boston lose 6-4 to Buffalo of all teams

Marchand+Pasta 0 pts

just sayin...... Top defensive forwards can be more valuable than point producers

 

[Holymakinaw]

one game without Bergeron, Boston lose 6-4 to Buffalo of all teams

Marchand 0 pts

Yup.

The three on that line have insane chemistry, and together they are a formidable foe.

Apart.......not so much.

 

[SnowblindNYR]

Imagine listing a single other lw in hockey over him that’s a complete joke. Panarin is nowhere near brads level.

Hilarious, Panarin is out-producing him on a points per game basis playing with Strome and a revolving door of young players/scrubs as the third player on that line. Joke post. Last year he played with Strome and Fast. "Nowhere near Brad's level". One of the worst takes I've read on this board.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

The top 3 should be Mcdavid Matthews and Mackinnon Marchand doesn't deserve it

 

[Lua]

Imagine listing a single other lw in hockey over him that’s a complete joke. Panarin is nowhere near brads level.

Panarin has the most even strength points in the past two years with less games played than McDavid, Drai, Matthews, Kane, and Marchand.

Playing with Ryan Strome, Jesper Fast, and Colin Blackwell.

You can potentially make a tenuous argument for Marchand over Panarin, but to say Panarin isn't even close is preposterous.