HankyZetts
Twi2ted
- Mar 16, 2004
- 3,348
- 393
Do the Habs need a heavyweight enforcer?
- Thread starter hototogisu
- Start date
- Status
Prust is 6' and 185 pounds, barely a middleweight and moen seems to not be willing to fight anymore
http://espn.go.com/nhl/team/roster/_/name/mtl/montreal-canadiens
I don't think he is 6'2" but the weight on others looks updated so 195lbs.
light-heavyweight . But why you compare them to Prust and Moen? They are better fighters
The gap between an enforcer and Armstrong isn't significant enough to dismiss the idea outright. I am for getting tougher. I am a true believer in having multiple dimensions to a hockey team. There will be nights when the skilled guys are off and aren't getting it done and a spark with a tough guy wouldn't hurt anymore than rolling Armstrong out there, and who knows, maybe it will help, maybe it won't, but I'd give it a shot.
Watching the habs get rag dolled is embarrassing and frustrating to players like gorges ect who have to defend themselves in positions they should never be in.
Get one and get one now. Time to start playing with a team mentality, these guys bring each other closer together, it may be difficult to quantify the impact, but there is no way it could hurt. Colby Armstrong brings no elements that would be missed, he's terrible.
Watching the habs get rag dolled is embarrassing and frustrating to players like gorges ect who have to defend themselves in positions they should never be in.
Get one and get one now. Time to start playing with a team mentality, these guys bring each other closer together, it may be difficult to quantify the impact, but there is no way it could hurt. Colby Armstrong brings no elements that would be missed, he's terrible.
What legit "hevyweights" has he fought and beaten?
Being 6'5" doesn't make you a heavyweight.
Okk sorry, the stats I posted were from nhl.com. Either way, he's still barely a middleweight. Thornton and co. are light heavyweights + they're very good fighters unlike prust, moen and armstrong.
That's like saying Toronto has a panzy team having to send Grabovsky after Prust to get clocked.
...or Boston having a panzy team since Krejci was the one trying to "take care" of Pouliot.
Even if you have 3 250lbs heavyweights on the 4th line, if the other team sends Orr after Plekanec, they won't be there to "jump in" unless the jump off the bench.
I'm not sure if you're quoting the wrong person here, and I'm generally against the idea of getting some big useless plug who does nothing but fight the other teams' enforcers, but you were straight up wrong in saying that white spanked mcquaid. Just calling a spade a spade.
HankyZetts
Twi2ted
- Mar 16, 2004
- 3,348
- 393
I forgot about that fight, thanks. No way White "spanked" him though, but he did hold his own.
Moen is 218lbs and can hold his own with pretty much anybody, but he doesn't fight for no reason.
I got the fights confused, but Mcquaid is far from a feared fighter, taht fight was pretty even until Mcquaid lost his jersey at which point while had little to grab(Rob Ray technique).
If last saturday night was not a good enough reason for him to fight, I wonder what it is going to take
White is a centre that can easy play on a 4th line. A heavyweight will not take is spot. If you want a tough team, you need multiple tough guy, not just 1 or 2. White toughness is a bonus. If you want to switch him with a softy, we will be at the same point than before
If last saturday night was not a good enough reason for him to fight, I wonder what it is going to take
What did you want him to do jump off the bench?
Orr was kicked out for 12 minutes and McLaren for 5 minutes at 15:01. There was no reason for him to fight before that.
Blind Gardien
nexus of the crisis
I think this is a key that can't be overlooked. We can argue all we want that Armstrong is not playing like somebody who is any clear cut above a plug goon. But does anybody think that Therrien is going to give his blessing to waiving Armstrong? Is White so irreparably lodged in the doghouse that you waive him... and how much of the purpose is served if you waive White anyway?
Trading Kaberle would help, but it's not clear that's going to be possible. A long term injury might come along too. Who knows.
At this time, though, there's just not a real way we can add the goon. There isn't room on the roster. We can speculate on guys to acquire, but have to realize that it can be nothing imminent. And who knows, once we start playing some other teams again and the ignominy of the Leafs game fades somewhat, perhaps it will seem less important again.
Tinordi is coming, the team can be looking at drafting some bigger tougher guys again too, and looking via free agency... I'd look at the size/toughness issue as just one more aspect of the overall building process. The team has to get better. Which in some degree likely includes getting tougher. Adding Prust was one step. There will be more steps taken, however. It doesn't all have to be today. I don't want to see any more Laraque mistakes, or give up assets for a plug player. Do it right, even if there isn't immediate gratification involved.
hototogisu
Poked the bear!!!!!
Okay, but that's still not answering the question. It's fine to say "get this guy" or "get that guy" but you can't add a body without shipping one out. So where does it start?
And if you keep White, are you comfortable with tying up 3 roster spots in forwards who will score maybe a combined 15 goals in an 82 game season? Are our other forwards consistent enough threats offensively that we can afford to do that? The shakey starts of Patches, DD, Cole and Gionta this year say no, it would seem.
Pleks, gio and co shouldn't have been on the ice at that time. We don't have any options to combat anything like this, we keep rolling the skill guys hoping them will get out of the funk. Gally, gally, gio, gorges, subban, need someone to mix it up for them when things get out of hand.
Those runs at our players take place because there is zero chance of us doing anything about it. Colby Armstrong is garbage, replacing him with garbage that can fight won't hurt a thing.
Pouliot and kreci are equal in the pansy department.
As far as your comment on grabs, I have no idea what you are talking about, that's grabs style, he'll do those things everywhere with anyone, he's fearless.
Getting a tough guy will not hurt a dman thing.
no he can't and the best guy he fighted is Thornton and it was a wresling boring fight.
So nobody takes runs or dirty hits at Bruin players? You should tell Marchand and Bregeron that.
- Status
Ad
Latest posts
-
-
-
Pre-Game Talk: Oilers vs. Canucks - time to make Vancouver rainier than usual- Latest: PositiveCashFlow
-
