Nah, you've jumped to many conclusions here and made many assumptions.
Calling out "Appeal to academia" arguments isn't a suggestion that academic institutions are inherently bad sources of information. It's pointing out that just because somebody has attained a certain standing or made certain achievements, doesn't mean they should be immune to the same scrutiny we'd have of others. I'm sure we've all heard the "I'll take the word of the guy who went to Harvard over the guy who didn't" types of things in our day to day lives.
My rebuttal was fine. you may want to work on your wording, and frustrations about academia, and so that you don't make it appear that you are rejecting it, dispelling it. Without realizing it you made an argument AGAINST academia, what it represents to you, and to the extent that you indicated how frustrated you were with it. That is a dangerous opinion, and its illogical. I mean you can further going there I guess, if you want, and preferring other types of information other than scientific, but I would caution against it.
Now that said I don't actually think your post was all that good or even accurately expressed what you would think about information. probably it was just a frustrated post in which you misstated some things. In anycase your add on information contained in this post is different than what could be ascertained from the post I originally replied to.
But this is also why we should state information, and our opinion, or are beliefs or what we feel to be knowledge, empirical truths more carefully than we tend to do, this applying to all of us.
ftr this is the post by you, that I had replied to;
This just sounds like more "appeal to academia" argument. Institutes of so-called higher education are famous for encouraging group think and ostracizing professors and/or researchers who promote views contrary to the officially sanctioned ones. Maybe I'm off base, but these veiled notions that all us plebs just need to shut up and listen to the university-educated enlightened is growing tiresome.