Yeah extrapolating stats are tough but we're talking about a guy who is under thirty and scores a good chunk of his goals Holmstrom style so I doubt that dries up completely.
If it means having a 20 goal guy for 4 million that can pla on the PP and one of the top lines to protect Datsyuk or Zetterberg I'm alright with it. I would rather do that than have a pure goon on the fourth line personally. Although if I were Holland I would take a serious look at Bourdeleau
I'd be more open to it, if we had more scoring to surround a guy like Clarkson. If we're going for a big body, and looking to spend around the $5m Clarkson is rumored to be looking at, I'd probably go with Horton. Not as physical, but still a big body, still willing to go to the net, and more likely to put up the goals that would justify the money. After that, probably Clowe, mostly because he's a bit bigger and he's put up a string of 55+ point seasons.
With our roster crunch, though, I'd put a premium on adding a goal scorer before anything. If we want to try to add a big guy, with some skill and some fighting ability, our best bet is probably a trade, though.