The truth is (most Hawk fans will disagree with me) I think this trade is a win - win.
I grew up in Chicago but live in Florida pretty much between Sunrise and Tampa. I attend several games a year at each place.
I’m a Stillman fan from when he was a Panther.
Dmen take time. Big Dmen take longer.
Stillman is just hitting the age where young big Dmen become regulars yet he played a lot of 2nd pair minutes last year.
I think 2 yrs from now he ends up a very good 2nd pairing guy able to cover for a more offensive partner.
You will be happy with the deal no matter how Dickinson turns out.
Oh, I'm not lamenting the trade at all. It cost a lot to pull off, but we payed a 3rd for Dermott and somehow got a 3rd for Hamonic last year. A second for a youngish physical, defensively minded D isn't.....well it's not miles out of line from that valuation.
And Dickinson was not a good fit here, injury or no, and his missing cap hit has been put to good use.
I don't have super high hopes for Stillman becoming a star D, but he still could be a useful, bottom or middle pairing physical D, akin to Schenn for us. It was an expensive add, but Stillman (replacing Dermott at almost the same cap hit) and 1.3 million of cap space still has some potential upside for us.