I don't want to blame the victim but Carlson turning his back on Reaves in front of the net wasn't smart either. He completely lost Nosek on the GWG and didn't even realize that lane had opened up. Just way too much lazy puck watching from him. It's in large part why he put himself in the position to be cross-checked by Reaves to begin with. Why square up with the puck handler behind the net there? Niskanen apologized for his G5 performance last series but this was far worse on a fundamental level IMO. It's a big stage, he plays a lot and Vegas really brings the pace but he absolutely must be smarter and more aware.
You'd hope they went to school on the video and will have learned their lesson in terms of the defensive firmness, awareness and the general second effort needed to stop them. It's not going to be easy but puck watching in a man defense really can't happen. Certainly not to that extent. A split focus, sure, but not to the point of being mesmerized. Do your job.
I disagree somewhat there. I think there were different decisions that could have been made that might have played better, but some of the goals were exactly how the Caps are designed to play them and others weren't exactly his fault.
Goal 1: He is going for the shot block which is what that defender on the Caps PK does all the time. Good shot beat a Holtby that was leaning the other way.
Goal 2: I don't have an excuse for him. He should not have gone out that side of the net other than since he is a right shot, he is usually on that side of the ice.
Goal 4: He is caught a bit out of position between going for that loose puck and staying home, so he is a bit late to the net front. He goes for the box out instead of engage face-to-face. Caps D try not to engage in front of the net too much as they prefer their sticks to be free to sweep rebounds away. If he had not been cross-checked to the ice, he was in prefect position to cancel any net front play.
Goal 5: Wow, he was on the ice for a lot of goals against. This is the classic turnover leading to a goal. Carlson is in position for a shot block expecting the center or other D to be there for the cross-ice pass as that is his job there. Eller flies the zone expecting DSP to get it out. Beagle sticks to wing instead of covering for Eller, and Kempny picks up the man passed to him from Beagle and goes for the stick lift on Reaves rather than play the puck (that is the big mistake on this goal IMO).