1. Our defense is already better without Schultz and JJ.
2. We added Marino last year. That was huge. He should only get better with his high hockey IQ.
3. We have POJ who continues to get better. Signed Maniscalco who looks like will at least be a solid bottom pair Dman. Then there is Reilly, Lee, etc.
While also having Petts who is still only 24.
Our D is fine. Now and going forward imo.
I agree, Rutherford has brought in a ton of youth on the defense in the last 2 years. Marino, Pettersson, and Matheson all in mid to low 20's and also trading and signing players like POJ, Maniscalco, and Lee. I personally think our defense is in a good spot both in young players on the team and prospects close to NHL ready. Letang is the only defenseman not in his 20's so it is not like we have a ton of room for players to come in anytime soon.
Rutherford also done a great job with making our wingers much younger and faster by adding Zucker and Kapanen recently. Also drafting Poulin and signing one of the top college FA's in O'Connor. Wingers are all in prime with not many openings coming soon either. I am fine with our winger situation both now and for the foreseeable future.
Centers are something we could use but let's face it no Center picked even in the middle of the 1st will ever come close to replacing a Crosby or Malkin. Those replacements will have to come from a couple years of tanking.
Goaltending was our 2nd biggest need beside Center. The difference is these two picks can turn into our next Jarry and Murray and can provide years of cheap quality goaltending. Those two have a much better chance of becoming starting goaltenders for the Pens than any Center we could of drafted becoming a good top 2 line Center. Our history of drafting goaltenders is much better than drafting Centers outside the very top of the 1st round.
Those rankings of our prospects mean nothing. They have been saying that for years and the Pens have added many quality players over those years. Guentzel, Rust, and Murray helped win Cups along with many other players to a lesser extent. Prospects are overrated anyways. It doesn't matter if you draft the young players or trade for young players such as Pettersson, Marino, and Kapanen. As long as you keep the team young around the core your doing your job and Rutherford has done a great job of that. Give these goalies a chance. I sure will and believe they can provide more value than any player drafted after them. Time will tell.