Nice backhanded compliment. Burns would have scored the same or more on almost any other team this year, including the Senators.
Sens fans always gotta find a way to knock Burns even when they're trying to look like they're complimenting him.
Wait? SJ is perfect for him and he is perfect for them. They've allowed him to be maximize his abilities. How is that a back-handed compliment?
But really though, the rarer thing is a defenseman leading the league in shots. That hasn't happened for a long time and only a very elite few have done it.
Burns SET his own arbitrary cutoff by having 75 points in back to back years. Had he scored 76 last year, we would say he was the first player since Leetch with back to back years of 76 points. Had he scored 74 this year we would say the same.
You know whats rare? Going 82p in 82 games, top5 in scoring and 1st in assist. Karlsson had better season last year that wasnt rewarded.
cool stuff.
Erik Karlsson is the first player to follow up a 81+ point season with a 71+ point season since the same year, so. I don't know, that's also an achievement I guess.
I would call burns an awesome accomplishment if he was the clear leader in point/ppg during those two years, but as it is, he is second in both. Then it only becomes a play with numbers.
his goal total during those years are really impressive however.
Looks like we're criticizing Burns for staying healthy now...
80+ and 70+ is even more arbitrary than back-to-back 75.
Let's break it down shall we.
We have 164 consecutive regular season games separated into 2 seasons at a certain point in time. During those 164 games Karlsson had 153 points and Burns had 151.
The only thing Burn managed to do is to distribute his points more equal at either side of the point in time that separates the seasons.
Lets just make a trophy for the player with the most consistent back to back seasons and call it the NHL Public Relations memorial trophy in the memory of the most stupid achievement ever made up.
Hey, the Norris Trophy is a big enough joke already nowadays where most points reign supreme, the fact that they have a Richard trophy but don't have one for being offensive defenseman of the year is a joke in itself.
I don't get why we don't have a Norris Trophy for outstanding overall defensive play and then a Orr Trophy for outstanding offensive production by a defenseman. The league is still behind.
I don't agree with this. I don't find multiples of 5s arbitrary at all. People say back-to-back 25 goal seasons, back-to-back 35 goal seasons all the time. It's not as impressive as 30 or 40, but that doesn't make it arbitrary. To equate it to something truly arbitrary like 23 or 72 is ridiculous. It's funny how if Karlsson just got a few more points this season, he'd also be included in this, and you know every Karlsson fan would gushing all over it.
You know what else is rare? Not seeing a Karlsson post on the 1st page of any defenseman topic. Sooo much insecurity.
Have they really? Burns had 47 points with his most recent season with the Wild and then 36 points in his subsequent season with San Jose. He led the team in goals, assists, and points this year. Nobody else even had 70 points and only one guy had more than 52. 3 other guys had 25 or more goals, but nobody besides those 3 had over 11.
Burns +/- was +19, only 3 other guys were +10 or better, and one of them was his defensive partner.
I honestly think if Burns was an Oiler, he would have 90 points. San Jose would be a lottery team if not for Burns, I'm not sure that's certainly a perfect fit. You could argue the Oilers are a perfect fit for McDavid, since he scored 100 points, but are they really? Probably not, as they lack a #1 offensive D like Burns. I would agree San Jose is a good fit for Burns, especially when you consider he and Pavelski have a D-F shot-tip chemistry that no other D-F have in the league, but your post is misinformed and obviously looks to insult Burns.
Not really. Despite what Karlsson fans think, the universe does not revolve around him. This thread is solely and completely about impressive, back-to-back seasons by Burns. Full stop.
Bringing up Karlsson in this thread is just irrelevant.
it's not the same thing at all. the same thing would be someone making a karlsson thread and then people rushing in to downplay it and talk about burns.
Not if Karlsson is the better player.
Not if Karlsson is the better player.