cgf
FireBednarsSuccessor
Not sure what you mean. I said that they are not more inconsistent than the average player. The curve of their productions, the coming and going of points doesn't seem to vary from other players. It's just second line scorers who always gets knocked for not being "consistent". Because when they are hot, the score at first line pace, and when they are cold they score at bottom six pace and it gets very noticeable. A third liner or a fourth liner gets away with their cold stretches in a different way. But pretty much everyone have their average production rate and the same types of curves between hot and cold.
Yeah. I mean, can anybody name a second liner who scores exactly .7 points per game over the course of an entire season and never goes cold? If you're scoring 55-ish points in the NHL, you're almost certainly going to have a few solid 2-3 point games mixed in with some games where you post 0, and it averages out to second line forward production over the course of 82 games. Nothing wrong with that. It's why they're second line forwards instead of core players.
Which is the problem with 2nd liners that don't contribute away from the puck when cold & why there's often a lot more emphasis on consistency in those other contributions than in scoring, when it comes to 2nd liners. Kadri's a highend 2nd liner, so it's unfair to compare his offensive contributions with theirs, but it's not unfair to look at his ability to continue to contribute, even when not scoring. Which just has not ever been Boedker or Bura's game when they can't score...thus why their inconsistent production is so much more of an issue than similarly inconsistent producers who are much more consistent contributors (if that distinction makes more sense now).
It's ok for elite scorers like Gaudreau or MacK to do little against the puck because they can be relied upon to produce...or at least drive chance creation and even when they are cold getting them going again is more important than having the forecheck harder or w/e...but if you're an inconsistent producer like Bura or Boedker, it's imperative that you can still do something to help, even when you're cold.