Predicting when each first-round QB should and will make his debut as an NFL starter
Josh Allen, Bills
Should debut: Week 5, vs.
Titans
Will debut: Week 5, vs. Titans
The Bills start the season with a gauntlet; at the Ravens, home against the Chargers, at the Vikings, and at the
Packers. Buzz's girlfriend. Woof. In a roundabout way,
Nathan Peterman was the sacrificial lamb for the Bills against the Chargers' outrageous pass-rush in the November disaster for Buffalo in 2017, and I think he could take on a similar role early in the 2018 campaign.
I'm not a betting guy, but if I was, the +820 for Peterman to start Week One would be very close to a no-brainer. The Bills coaches like Peterman a lot, and it wouldn't surprise me if he's steadier in camp than Allen and McCarron, although he's extremely unlikely to provide the "wow" throws Buffalo's 2018 first-rounder can.
The Bills defense will keep them in games in September, yet 0-4 seems reasonable and a 2-2 start would be outstanding. Either way, that home outing against
Tennessee seems like
the logical time for Allen to make his Bills debut. The Titans defense won't be brutal this season, but it probably won't be as menacing up front as the squad's in Baltimore,
Minnesota, or Los Angeles (units that finished 3rd, 2nd and 6th in
Football Outsiders' Defensive DVOA in 2017), and having Allen start in Green Bay against
Aaron Rodgers simply wouldn't be doing right by the young quarterback.
Even one month on the sideline would be much more beneficial to Allen's chance to succeed in the NFL in Buffalo than starting him right away.