While I don't mind Liles as a player and the length is no issue at all with me, I don't like the contract value. I would have preferred to have gone with Cross or waited to dip into the free agency pool to see if we could land Russel.
We're still in the hunt for Russel and while I also like him as a player, he's best suited as a bottom pairing guy at this point. Having both Liles and Russel while also keeping Chara and Krug doesn't make sense to me unless we plan on moving out McQuaid and plan on having two smallish vets on the 3rd pairing. But, if that's the case, then why buyout Seids and tell him one of the reasons why we're letting him go is because we're going with the kids? Signing Liles and going after Russel kind of flies in the face of that.
Overall, I don't think this was a signing they had to do, especially on the first day.