Any one of McAvoy, Krug, or Carlo play in the Top 4 of every single team in the NHL. No team that I can see have 4 D-men better than any of these guys.
no doubt none of them are 5th on the depth chart of any team... but the question remains do they compliment each others skill sets as a group and is the collective value of them larger then the sum of their parts?
i would argue also that krug shouldnt be trotted out there in the traditional usage that a top 4 dman gets... he will end up overmatched if hes getting too many d-zone starts against elite opposition.
overall, krug brings enough value to be considered one of the top 2-3 most valuable defenders on a team... but hes not well suited for defending in his own zone under preasure. using guys to their strengths is a good thing.
its like baseball... you bat your speedy guy who draws walks at the top of your lineup... you bat your muscel bound guy thats swinging for the fences and striking out a lot in the 4th or 5th spot in the lineup.
McAvoy and to a lesser extent vaakainen install confidence into me that they will be 20+ min all-situation dmen that do nicely fit the traditional definition of top pair dmen.
carlo and krug feel more like 'specialists' but ones that can add a great value when utilized to their strengths.
for as long as chara keeps playing... he too is a specialist now... he also is one hell of a great example for young guys to expire towards following his leadership. it screams that he could be an amazing bottom pair guy breaking people in.
once chara is gone... we have some guys im looking forward to seeing
zboril/lauzon both have intriguing possibility to work their way into the top 4 conversation... if either can make that jump then we can see krug falling into his comfortable role as a specialist on the bottom pair.
it leaves grzelyck and moore on the outside looking in. keeping 1 around until vaakainen gets established isnt the worst possible thing. but keeping both seems like an unnecesarry overkill use of our cap space.
axel andersson is starting to make noise that we have to factor him in at some point... im not sure I like the idea of him and krug together though... not sure he will fit behind McAvoy/carlo. meanwhile Clifton is in the mix and he does seem more like an ideal bottom pair guy behind guys like McAvoy and carlo.
to me its about mixing and matching a variety of balanced skill sets to make the whole unit achieve its maximum potential.
the very first guy in this mix that is at the end of his rope is kevan miller. Clifton is more affordable in the bottom pair... carlo is more skilled as a defensive shutdown guy. chara is moving into the role as guy who can fight the 1-2 times its actually necessary in any given season. and moore has the existing signed contract to hang around as the 7th dman for the time being.
I would expect kevan miller to be gone within a week or two of getting off the IR