Northern Avs Fan
Registered User
- May 27, 2019
- 21,970
- 29,648
Islanders must have one f***ing awesome defense if Toews was their #5 but becomes a #2 on a SC contender.
I get that he can be Makar's partner until Byram is ready but to label him as a #2/#3 in a vacuum is just not right.
The Isles played most of their top-4/5 defencman similar minutes last year. Much like the Avs, except their 3/4/5/6 guys were better than Colorado’s.
If you judge by minutes played at 5V5 you likely won’t think Toews is very good. When he played he was very effective though.
In Colorado he’s being asked to be a #3 defenceman. I think that’s right around where his ability is at.
And honestly, I think it was @Bender who brought this point up on the main board. Isles fans saying, “he’ll get eaten alive on the top pair.” They don’t realize that playing on the top pair with Cale Makar is a lot different than being paired with Scott Mayfield. Makar makes life a lot easier for his partner.
Bednar is going to play all three pairs again this season imo. If they Avs end up with a Byram - Johnson 3rd pair those guys are going to get some ice too. So, while Toews will probably be asked to play a couple more 5V5 minutes with the Avs I don’t expect it to be an issue, with their defensive depth and the players around him.