All the Barrie supporters keep mentioning the substantial offensive loss, but they ignore some of the pedigree of the possible alternatives.
Consider their Junior careers on the basis of their drafted year.
- Girard - 67 Games @ 74 points (QMJHL 2015/16);
- Makar - 54 Games @ 75 points (AJHL 2016/17);
- Timmins - 67 Games @ 61 Points (OHL 2016/17);
- Meloche - 44 Games @ 34 Points (QMJHL 2014/15)
- Barrie - 68 Games @ 52 Points (WHL 2008/09)
Barrie had a stellar WHL career and struggled in the AHL. This might not be definitive of being a future NHL star, but the evidence can be a yardstick of their potential.
Supporters of Barrie ignores that each of the 4 prospects already better defensively. Only 1 of 4 need to be comparable to his offensive output to justify a move. This doesn't even include the players in return for Barrie and 2019 Draft.
So a replacement is within reach and the odds of replacing Barrie with this surplus of DMen can be justify to improve the team.