Please give me some specific examples of what he could/should have done differently here?
Should he have overpayed Burmie substantially to keep him?
Should he have forced Noel to play Kulda when we were playing well down the playoff stretch.
Should we have given Telegin a spot on the Jets without him earning it to appease him?
I am sorry but there are things to blame Chevy for (Pavelic) but what else was he supposed to do here. Kulda cleared waivers for goodness sake, he wasn't getting anything for him in a trade. Chevy allegedly had solid deals lined up for Burmie but they all fell through probably because Burmie wasn't willing to sign for what those teams were offering.
Telegin was entering the 2nd year of his contract and the Jets had every desire to continue developing him but he elected to just leave. Not sure what could have been done here.
I have been a Cheveldayoff supporter since day one. I gave him the benefit of the doubt several times.
I do agree about Burmistrov. I don't think there was a sane way to resolve that issue (outside of perhaps intervening in the Noel situation but I am not a huge fan of the GM meddling in on ice stuff like that). Telegin should have never been released. Kulda should have been given an opportunity to play. That is one instance where the GM has to step up, IMO.
I guess the thing that really annoys me is these assets fly out the door. You say that Kulda doesn't play because the team is playing well down the stretch (which doesn't include all the other opportunities to get him on the roster). So basically you don't play a player because you want to make the playoffs, yet you won't sacrifice a 2nd round pick to make a push for the post season. There is a real contradiction there. Either Chevy is a poor asset manager, or he is a bad talent assessor. You pick your poison.
You can call what I am saying rhetoric, but I have never 'blamed everything on Chevy'. I do have the right to question him, which is what I am really starting to do. He seems unwilling to pull the trigger on anything that isn't %100 safe. He seems to have a problem with either identifying the teams problems or being able to take the steps needed to rectify them.
You can say "what could Chevy do?" all day and night. The fact of the matter is, good GM's act. You don't have to blow up your measured approach wrt drafting and developing in order to make meaningful changes to improve your roster, NOW and I don't think Chevy is savvy enough to do that.
All I've really seen from him is his desire to keep things status quo. Re-sign the players he has (good or bad) and just hope for the best.
Freud said the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.
EDIT: Finally, I would like to take issue with the notion that if you question a player, a coach, a GM that all of the sudden you are part of some hate bandwagon. This board is for discussion of just these things. We can't all be cheerleaders of every player and every thing the org and players do. That would make it super boring around here.
I gave Noel a chance for a LONG time. He did things that made me lose faith in him.
Cheveldayoff is going down that same path. I still have hope he can get this thing back on the rails but to me, this summer will say a LOT about him as a GM and initial indications are not good. I guess we will see.