I don't think Eberle alone gets Hamonic, but I also can't help feel that both guys are on opposite ends of the spectrum as to how they're viewed.
Eberle is, and continues to be, undervalued. He's been a consistent scorer since entering the league, despite what has been a bit of a trainwreck in Edmonton.
On the other hand, I can't help but feel Hamonic is overvalued. He's a very good defenseman, but not someone I'd put in the upper tier --- nor do I see him being on the cusp of being in the upper tier.
I don't think any deal would have been terribly far off with those guys are starting points. Though it certainly wasn't going to get done by throwing in a spare part either.