The Canadian division excuse is pretty overblown. The bottom two teams in the Central, bottom two in the Pacific, and bottom three in the East all have a worst goal differential than VAN and OTT.
The top 10 scoring teams in the league (GF/G):
2 East
2 North
3 West
3 Central
The bottom 10 defensive teams in the league (GA/G):
3 East
2 North
3 West
2 Central
The North has 5 teams in the top half of best GA/G in the league.
The excuse for what, individual success? General scoring? Overall competitiveness?
It’s a less competitive division specifically for the playoff spot for the most obvious reason, they only have 7 teams. (That’s why this season has driven Canadian GM mental, not making the playoffs feels like a potentially fireable offensive for everybody but Dorion.)
I look at the competition for the fourth playoff spot as the best tell for how good a division is. My problem with Scotia North is 1) that after their much celebrated 9-4-2 start the Habs have been 15-16-7, 99 GF 118 GA, 2) the Habs weirdly look better than the Jets, who have imploded in their 1-7-0 death spiral, 14 GF 28 GA, but the Jets have two games left with the Canucks so they may still come in 3rd.
The Jets have fewest regulation wins (22), smallest goal differential (+13) and fewest points (9 less then the 4th place NYI and 12 less than BOS/MIN). They do have four games left though. Hellebuyck can only do so much with a defense this atrocious though and the whole team is a mess.
Montreal has 20 regulation wins, -6 goal differential and two less points then the Jets with one less game left. I guess you can debate which divisions have worse fourth place team.
The Athletic power rankings has 12) NYI 13) STL 14) NSH 15) MTL 16) WPG 17) NYR 18) DAL 19) PHI.
I’m not going just by that, the overall points it takes to make the playoffs in the 4th spot is easiest way to see the competitive mean. The East is the most competitive and we’ll have to see where the other divisions end up. The Discover Central still looks like the second most competitive to me. Each team only plays each other teams 8 or 9 times, the extremes at each end matter less.