Poor Buffalo, I think they'll be spinning their tires for a while yet. They remind me of the decade of darkness here, with the team thinking that they were being progressive/clever by hiring rookie coaches like Eakins and Krueger, or promoting a rookie GM like Tambellini. Having a coach/GM tandem with experience has done wonders for the Oilers in only a year. I think Buffalo needs to hire people with a history of success at the NHL level to go anywhere at this point.
I also feel bad for them and wonder what the root of the problem is. They are a couple years short of our decade of darkness and are also better positioned than we were with a elite #1 center in Eichel and a elite #1 defenseman in Dahlin.
I feel Buffalo has had a decent team on paper on and off for awhile. Better than Edmonton in the decade of darkness. They also are in a much weaker Division than Edmonton was during those tough years. So... You cant cant help but feel the problem has to be the organization to some extent.
I might wander over to the Buffalo board and ask what the consensus is on what is wrong. Edmonton's problems were pretty easily spotted during the decade of darkness, Buffalo not so much. Edmonton's problems imo:
-Not enough center or defense talent/depth. Average to weak goaltending. A bunch of talented wingers just doesn't work. So poorly constructed and just bad on paper.
-Poor drafting. Premium drafting opportunity for a decade plus and we have relatively little to show for it.
-A brutal Pacific Division/Western Conference with big heavy teams that we just couldn't compete with in skill or size. Tough travel as well.
-Numerous bad and/or inexperienced coaches/gms.
-An organization known for its lack of professionalism and integrity. A club where direction and organization were reportedly lacking/confusing. Neopitism at its worst.
Im not 100% sold the last 2 items have been fixed yet. We won't know for a couple years but the team itself is far more balanced and deep. Some of our current success has to do with the Pacific/West just being that much worse as well.
As for Buffalo i don't think they have any of those same problems save maybe the last one or two...?