Lol. If he played anywhere else he wouldn't even be ranked as a top ten player.
I like Ferraro's game by game analysis, but his overall judgment of stars has always been lacking IMO. Super heavily driven by team success, like most media guys.
It's a more ridiculous version of Ovechkin vs Crosby back in 2010-2012 or so. At least at that time, Crosby probably
was better than Ovechkin overall, but the amount of hate Ovie got because his team didn't get a cup was absurd. It's now flipped the other way - the media is just non-stop hailing the 'resurgence' of Ovie, and his 'newfound defensive commitment'. It's bullshit. Ovie has been backchecking since the Dale Hunter days just fine. Just no one noticed because all they saw were the usual highlights of him one timing 50 goals a year.
Now with McDavid, the fact that he plays for a tire fire of a team means Matthews gets way more credit for 'two way play' despite his team bleeding way more chances against than the defencely suspect Oilers. It's even dumber than Ovie-Crosby because McDavid is better than Matthews in pretty much every way except goalscoring. It is what it is. I just hope we start winning so we don't get too much more of this stupidity.