It shouldn't be meaningless, but has been made meaningless in several ways.
All Star selection ought to be pretty prestigious and maybe be worth something at contract or bonus time, but you can never have that with each team needing representation and fan voting.
If you're not a bona fide superstar or in the best say 7 d, 13 f and 3 g in your conference then too bad.
I love to see an all star game, but only if they really are all stars.
I'm a Vancouver fan, but couldn't complain if none got picked.
The teams ought be picked by a panel of journalists and retired former all stars from their respective conferences. It's nothing less than a sham game with no PK Subban. The likes of Jagr ought to be in there too.
If you were picking a team to play Mars for the future of civilisation, Subban would be right in there while so host of those voted 'all stars' wouldn't get a whiff.